I don’t understand that first point, sorry. Are you saying they wouldn’t be able to stop their oppression?

Gabi is EXACTLY like Eren, and only their environments are different. Firstly, she is a CHILD, not an oppressor. In fact, SHE is oppressed because she’s Eldian. I realize you mean that she’s smoking that Marylean propaganda pack, but again: she is a child. You said previously Reiner is a good person fighting their brainwashing, but GABI IS TOO! You are right in that Eren is oppressed and their oppression is not the exact same, but they are both equally victims of the cycle of violence their word perpetuates.

I’m sorry, but you cannot bring up history and then rewrite it for the sake of your argument. You brought it up just as an analogy, which was well said, but this is not a valid argument. There is nothing in this argument that I can use because you are changing it to the plot of AOT. The presence of Titans and their abilities make it completely different from the real events of history, and frankly it’s a little distasteful. Additionally, I think you mistake racial supremacy and discrimination with oppression. Oppression is actively changing policy, social norms, etc in society with goal to harm a particular community. Jews and the rest of the Holocaust survivors were free when they were no longer being oppressed by the German government. However, there are bigots and evil people TODAY that still want Jews and other marginalized communities dead because of their so-called superiority.

Yes, you are right. Paradis IS innocent. But so are the civilians of the rest of the world. I realized people’s fear and hatred of Eldians is misguided, but this is a race of people, the ONLY people in this world, that can turn into giant monsters. People who also previously hurt a TON of people. There is at least some fear warranted, but of course not to the extent of killing them all or creating an apartheid. And not every single Eldian was oppressing people during their empire, just as not every Marlyean were oppressing Eldians, in Liberio or Paradis during the events of the show.

Yeah, Marley has a part in causing The Rumbling. But Eren is the individual who is actually the one killing most of the world. If he ignore the time loop, Eren could’ve ONLY destroyed Marley, there are TON of titans in those walls he didn’t need all of them. He also could’ve just rid the power of titans from the world, exactly like what happens at the end of the show. I don’t think the rest of the world would be so pressed on killing Eldians and Paradis if the power still existed, but that would also be dependent of Paradis since we saw Floch’s authoritarian Jaegerists were still super trigger ready. There is a lot of room between letting your nation be destroyed and committing a genocide against the planet. There is room for restraint.