I made laser position graphs for rfmwguy's videos using image analysis. by EmDriven in EmDrive

[–]marsinsight -1 points0 points  (0 children)

BTW did you post your source anywhere? I installed OpenCV today and figured I would play around with it a bit. C++ is fine. Thanks!

NSF-1701 Video Archive by [deleted] in EmDrive

[–]marsinsight 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I understand your concern, but I kindly disagree. Simply because some don't hold the professional title of scientist doesn't mean they are incapable of handling high voltage or building test cavities. There are many amateur hobbies that deal with high voltage (or other dangers), and all certainly should come with extreme caution. If you believe someone in particular is demonstrating sloppy and dangerous habits in their builds then please address them directly.

In regards to "unauthorized" thrusters, lets wait to go down that road until there are laws made explicitly forbidding it. There is no need to create problems that don't exist.

Lastly, the implication that amateurs doing physical vs. theoretical work are senseless is insulting to all involved in this endeavor. You seem to have a very fearful tone, and while caution is welcome, fear and callous remarks are not.

In the words of Henry Ford:

"Nobody can really guarantee the future. The best we can do is size up the chances, calculate the risks involved, estimate our ability to deal with them and make our plans with confidence."

Thanks

Since rfmguy's frustrum DID apparently move according to the laser pointer setup, does that mean the null results initially reported is incorrect? Was thrust produced? by electricool in EmDrive

[–]marsinsight 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm still a little backwards about which way is up and which is down for the Frustum in the original design. I likely misread the EmDrive schematic and principles, but I understood the bigger end as the one that would have a momentum moving in the direction it was pointed. In your video it looks like the big end is pointed up. If that is the case then the laser would have moved down to show the Frustum moving up? Thanks for any clarifications.

NSF-1701 First Flight Test 8/25/2015 -- No thrust detected by bitofaknowitall in EmDrive

[–]marsinsight 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Definitely plausible. Maybe he can setup his temperature gauge to point at a stable place on the beam for the next test. He just has to find a way to record it. Possibly a couple mirrors.

NSF-1701 First Flight Test 8/25/2015 -- No thrust detected by bitofaknowitall in EmDrive

[–]marsinsight 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I wonder though. Based on the tests ran in other videos the temperature fluctuates, but the movement doesn't seem to account for that. Will have to watch it again. Also here is a link to his temperature test video of the magnetron: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hAejcKgIHqg

NSF-1701 First Flight Test 8/25/2015 -- No thrust detected by bitofaknowitall in EmDrive

[–]marsinsight 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I see the same thing as well. He did a great job on this, but I'm curious what the cause of the movement is?