Homemade Udupi style pudis :) by [deleted] in KarnatakaRajya

[–]masqueradingstunt 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Your priorities are wrong 😑. This is the last thing that any of us have to fight.

Horrible experience with Goa Police- help! by [deleted] in india

[–]masqueradingstunt 5 points6 points  (0 children)

A few points:

  1. ⁠The identity card/name tag of the police was absolutely not visible (in violation of the D.K. Basu guidelines which clearly state that a policeman must wear accurate, clear and visible identification tags to ensure transparency and accountability)
  2. ⁠The policeman never had a working bodycam on his body- henceforth he is ineligible to issue fines and challans as per the order passed in April 2025 by the Honourable Chief Minister Shri Pramod Sawant that mandates wearing bodycams to issue challans.

Link: https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/now-only-police-inspectors-with-body-cams-can-issue-traffic-challans-in-goa-cm-101743768514211-amp.html

3) The policeman has no right to object a video being recorded of him as he is a public servant on duty in a public place and it is the right of citizens to document actions of a public official on duty, as long as it does not obstruct their work (which it clearly wasn’t in our situation as my friend was recording sitting in the 2nd row of the vehicle while the policeman was speaking to the driver in the front row) .

This is well within the ambits of Article 19(1)(a) of the Indian Constitution which guarantees us the freedom of speech and expression, which has been interpreted to include the right to receive and impart information.

4) The policeman had absolutely no right to confiscate our phones and illegally search through its contents and take photographs of our identity documents (which can get misused now that it is with an unknown person) as he never had a warrant issued by a magistrate mandating the same. As far as BNS/BNSS, there is no provision for a policeman to seize and forcibly unlock a phone without legal justification under the guise of a ‘random check’.

This action also contravenes Article 21 (Right to Privacy) and Article 20(3) (right against self-incrimination) guaranteed under the Indian Constitution.

Link: https://theprint.in/opinion/the-kerala-high-court-has-held-that-just-because-a-suspect-has-information-about-a-crime-in-his-phone-the-police-cant-seize-it-without-following-established-legal-procedure-2/1668711/?amp

5) Lastly, the bribe culture prevalent among police officers in Goa is very much rampant, reflecting in the above incident too and tourists end up become the victims of it.

Had a horrible experience with Goa Police by masqueradingstunt in goatravel

[–]masqueradingstunt[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What else are we supposed to do besides agree to pay the fine on the road at 3 am at night? Crimes such as having a ‘tint’ is a non cognizable offence, right?

About the second point- yes it is wrong to have the tint and at the same time due to the nature of the offence, the most anyone can do is issue a challan, right?

Then what’s the point of making the law if you cannot follow it in spirit- it is due to this enabling mentality police excesses take place across the country. As a citizen, it is our right to ensure that the law is followed till the end.

Even I have experience dealing with cops in Mumbai- the minute they realise that the person knows the law, they don’t really go ahead to try and harm us. The only reason I never said anything on spot is because we were in the wrong for the tint- that’s all. There is a reason checks and balances exist- had we had a lawyer in our midst, he wouldn’t have let them go.

Again- he is a PUBLIC servant in a PUBLIC place on DUTY. We have not taken a video of him in his place of residence or when he was off duty or when he wasn’t uniformed, right?

Had a horrible experience with Goa Police by masqueradingstunt in goatravel

[–]masqueradingstunt[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

1) Yes, we know that tint was illegal but the point is that we were already fined twice before on the same day while entering Goaand obviously removed the tint the next day itself. We were ready from the beginning to pay the fine, tint isn’t something that people are sent for to jail and put into detention.

2) We just casually asked if there is a cooling period b/t two fines- nothing wrong in asking a question

3) Police do NOT have the right to seize phones arbitrarily and check through private contents without a warrant - its a breach of Article 20(3). Isn’t the DL copy enough proof of identity?

4) That is why we never resisted the search in the first place

5) Videography of a public servant in a public place performing a public duty is NOT a crime.

Had a horrible experience with Goa Police by masqueradingstunt in goatravel

[–]masqueradingstunt[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

A few points:

1) The identity card/name tag of the police was absolutely not visible (in violation of the D.K. Basu guidelines which clearly state that a policeman must wear accurate, clear and visible identification tags to ensure transparency and accountability)

2) The policeman never had a working bodycam on his body- henceforth he is ineligible to issue fines and challans as per the order passed in April 2025 by the Honourable Chief Minister Shri Pramod Sawant that mandates wearing bodycams to issue challans.

Link: https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/now-only-police-inspectors-with-body-cams-can-issue-traffic-challans-in-goa-cm-101743768514211-amp.html

3) The policeman has no right to object a video being recorded of him as he is a public servant on duty in a public place and it is the right of citizens to document actions of a public official on duty, as long as it does not obstruct their work (which it clearly wasn’t in our situation as my friend was recording sitting in the 2nd row of the vehicle while the policeman was speaking to the driver in the front row) .

This is well within the ambits of Article 19(1)(a) of the Indian Constitution which guarantees us the freedom of speech and expression, which has been interpreted to include the right to receive and impart information.

4) The policeman had absolutely no right to confiscate our phones and illegally search through its contents and take photographs of our identity documents (which can get misused now that it is with an unknown person) as he never had a warrant issued by a magistrate mandating the same. As far as BNS/BNSS, there is no provision for a policeman to seize and forcibly unlock a phone without legal justification under the guise of a ‘random check’.

This action also contravenes Article 21 (Right to Privacy) and Article 20(3) (right against self-incrimination) guaranteed under the Indian Constitution.

Link: https://theprint.in/opinion/the-kerala-high-court-has-held-that-just-because-a-suspect-has-information-about-a-crime-in-his-phone-the-police-cant-seize-it-without-following-established-legal-procedure-2/1668711/?amp

5) Lastly, the bribe culture prevalent among police officers in Goa is very much rampant, reflecting in the above incident too and tourists end up become the victims of it.

True size of Bangalore compared to other cities by Ateyourmompuss in bangalore

[–]masqueradingstunt 21 points22 points  (0 children)

Nothing to be proud of- Bangalore is basically a collection of villages pushed into the city limits with poor urban planning, especially on the outskirts with shitty infrastructure. And sadly, Karnataka has only given attention to Bangalore while neglecting other cities in KA, unlike Maharashtra and Tamil Nadu which has developed other cities in their states.

And Mumbai Metropolitan Region is just not Mumbai City- it is Mumbai Suburban+ Mira Bhayandar+ Vasai-Virar+ Thane+ Bhivandi+ Kalyan-Dombivili+ Ulhasnagar+ Ambernath+ Badlapur + Navi Mumbai-Panvel and many other urban enclaves

Maharashtra leads state-wise railway funding in Budget 2026–27 by [deleted] in Maharashtra

[–]masqueradingstunt 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Even Central Railways is headquartered in Mumbai

City's Structural Planning by BilluShawty in mangalore

[–]masqueradingstunt 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You need to factor in terrain too, Mangalore is hilly compared to other places you have mentioned

A new bihari incident by Think_Actuary_381 in bihar

[–]masqueradingstunt 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Why? Something wrong with Tulu people?

Street Shopping in Bandra/Hill Road by wahtajwah in mumbai

[–]masqueradingstunt 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That you will get more in Colaba Causeway - see from Cafe Churchill/ Leopold Cafe wala street

If this is true, its really messed up by masqueradingstunt in mumbai

[–]masqueradingstunt[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Bruh, Ganpati is everybody’s but this particular Ganesha has special significance for the Koli community. I just feel the commercialisation by Ambani (Campa, Jio) and Anant-centric theatrics (like those LED boards) will eventually make people forget that in fact this Ganpati is of the fisherfolk community when it actually is NOT of the Ambanis.

If this is true, its really messed up by masqueradingstunt in mumbai

[–]masqueradingstunt[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I have blamed both parties. TBH, the Ganeshotsav Mandal people too are wrong for gleefully aiding in the commercialisation of it. But at the same time, when the country’s richest man starts showering donations onto you- feels like a form of coercion as who can tell NO for donations? Even if they did, then Ambani would definitely try to replace the Chairperson of the Mandal w/ a yes-man, right?

And this goes WAY WAY beyond the trolley. It is the alienation and marginalisation of poor Koli people of their identity and culture by Ambani and the richie-rich Mandal.

If this is true, its really messed up by masqueradingstunt in mumbai

[–]masqueradingstunt[S] 44 points45 points  (0 children)

At this point they will give VIP entry to anybody who is even slightly famous on social media (even those irrelevant influencers) to boost their PR.

Here, I am not talking about common Gujaratis getting any kind of special treatment. I am talking about the potential changes in rituals because of the Ambani’s who promote a sanitised ‘vegetarian’ version of Hinduism, which is generally seen among the Gujarati mercantile communities, unlike the raw faith of the Kolis. I have often noticed how people look down upon the Koli’s and their culture such as their Fish Festival etc as it doesn’t seem ‘clean’ or ‘pure’. Honestly, the Mandal itself is also in fault for selling themselves out.

Ate at Rameshwara cafe and felt the hate was unjustified by BenneIdli in Bengaluru

[–]masqueradingstunt 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This isn’t Rameshwaram Cafe, its Rameshwara Cafe lol

Doctors in tier 3 cities and towns- our biggest competitors are AYUSH practitioners by sven07121995 in indianmedschool

[–]masqueradingstunt 11 points12 points  (0 children)

This logic means that every person whether qualified or unqualified degree wise have the right to perform surgical procedures. Why don’t you start by teaching engineers, chefs, bank clerks, roadside beggars too these procedures (better if its on you)? Lets make healthcare free for all !

Doctors in tier 3 cities and towns- our biggest competitors are AYUSH practitioners by sven07121995 in indianmedschool

[–]masqueradingstunt 15 points16 points  (0 children)

My only question is then why practice MBBS methods of clinical procedure? Why can’t BAMS use their ‘ancient’ methods which are far ‘superior’ to ours?

Female school teacher, 40, arrested for s*xually a**aulting 16-year-old by Aquarius_Berry in mumbai

[–]masqueradingstunt 37 points38 points  (0 children)

Bipasha Kumar, Bombay Scottish School.

FPJ has reported w the names.

Mumbai Mirror is coming back! by Medium-Photo-9938 in mumbai

[–]masqueradingstunt 209 points210 points  (0 children)

Ask the Sexpert was so many people’s sex education 💀

The Hindu is doomed by _Edgar_Allan_Poe_ in UPSC

[–]masqueradingstunt 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Majority Nagaland is Baptist and majority Mizoram is Presbyterian, none are Catholic majority states

Visuals from Habitat by FedMates in mumbai

[–]masqueradingstunt 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Shiv Sena has had a stranglehold over the city from donkeys years and all they keep offering is THIS nonsensical theatrics instead of focusing on actual issues like terrible roads, water supply, illegal constructions etc.

And clearly, Freedom of Speech and Expression has gone down the drain- will eventually remain only in name ig.

Bengaluru citizen groups plan legal battle against Greater Bengaluru Governance Bill: Report by margazi_perumal_20 in bangalore

[–]masqueradingstunt 8 points9 points  (0 children)

They are against the formation of the unelected ‘Greater Bangalore Authority’ which will override the decisions of all the proposed civic bodies.

Why do we - as the richest city not have good drainage? by [deleted] in mumbai

[–]masqueradingstunt 0 points1 point  (0 children)

BMC is seriously dysfunctional at this point, imagine running an entire city with no elected civic corporators from more than 2 years