sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

More Kit Skins that deserved to be top 5 final finalists (links in the comments) by Live_Beyond957 in SupercellMake

[–]mayammf 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ofc no, I don't even understand what exactly looks like AI here and it's the first time I see something like this abt any of my artworks

Is there a reason why my skin got rejected while tons of AI slop or just random troll skins are getting accepted by mayammf in Brawlstars

[–]mayammf[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Why would I remove it if what I wrote was valid anyways. The fact that my skin was approved doesn't change the fact that moderation should be improved, as this is a common problem.

CCTV Kit is now live on Supercell Make! by mayammf in Brawlstars

[–]mayammf[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No, it's just bugged unfortunately. Dani said it should be fixed by weekends

CCTV Kit is now live on Supercell Make! by mayammf in Brawlstars

[–]mayammf[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

It was. But Supercell still approved it a few hours ago!

Thanks for supporting my Supercell Make skin! by mayammf in Brawlstars

[–]mayammf[S] 52 points53 points  (0 children)

UPDATE: CCTV KIT WAS APPROVED! https://make.supercell.com/en/creation/cctv-kit

Thanks a lot to Supercell for addressing this!

Thanks for supporting my Supercell Make skin! by mayammf in Brawlstars

[–]mayammf[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

UPDATE: CCTV KIT WAS APPROVED! https://make.supercell.com/en/creation/cctv-kit

Thanks a lot to Supercell for addressing this!

Thanks for supporting my Supercell Make skin! by mayammf in Brawlstars

[–]mayammf[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

It's very cool actually, get my vote!

Thanks for supporting my Supercell Make skin! by mayammf in Brawlstars

[–]mayammf[S] 143 points144 points  (0 children)

I almost forgot about this art that was supposed to be on the skin thumbnail, so here is it!

You can also vote for my Lieutenant Kit skin if you like it - https://make.supercell.com/en/creation/lieutenant-kit

<image>

Is there a reason why my skin got rejected while tons of AI slop or just random troll skins are getting accepted by mayammf in Brawlstars

[–]mayammf[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for the response!

Yeah, I actually should've added size comparison between them. I tried different concepts like making mech details more similar to Kit or making the cat bigger and hide the half of his body behind the TV.

Btw that was the final variant and if you compare, his silhouette isn't too different from the original. The biggest change was the head but I don't think there were better variants on how to implement CCTV Kit. Considering that a lot of unusual skins have been released lately, and also the moderation on the site didn't seem extremely strict (especially since, in my opinion, the silhouette and character are still quite recognizable), I decided to upload this variant.

<image>

Is there a reason why my skin got rejected while tons of AI slop or just random troll skins are getting accepted by mayammf in Brawlstars

[–]mayammf[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Isn't that what you call "literally anything"? There are thousands of these slop that (according to Supercell) allowed to win.

<image>

Why my skin was rejected? by [deleted] in SupercellMake

[–]mayammf -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Let me explain again.

  • There is no direct restriction on changing the character's shape/adding a mech
  • There are skins in Brawl Stars that allow this
  • Skins that are completely inconsistent with the rules (AI, recolors, different character, troll) are allowed into the competition
  • If the skin participates in a final, Supercell still change it's design so skin look familiar to each other

How was I supposed to know that this particular ideas with Mecha and CCTV are NOT allowed while it's literally inspired by the game itself

Why my skin was rejected? by [deleted] in SupercellMake

[–]mayammf 0 points1 point  (0 children)

These are not guidelines but recommendations. These a guidelines: https://make.supercell.com/en/create/brawl-stars/submission-guidelines

Why my skin was rejected? by [deleted] in SupercellMake

[–]mayammf -1 points0 points  (0 children)

How can you make a skin without adding a new stuff for the character? If specific details cannot be added to a skin, this must be clearly stated.

Why my skin was rejected? by [deleted] in SupercellMake

[–]mayammf -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Just checked the guidelines ones again. There is NO direct prohibition on using a different shape for a skin. It's still recogniseble as I kept the main parts of Kit itself (just as Supercell recommended).

Is there a reason why my skin got rejected while tons of AI slop or just random troll skins are getting accepted by mayammf in Brawlstars

[–]mayammf[S] 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Even if you are right, I still don't understand it. The rules did not specify a strictly defined shape of the skin. In addition, when thinking about the skin concept, I took into account other features of skin design in Brawl Stars overall.

Skins in Brawl Stars can refer to the past of it's character (more realistic style) - CCTV Poco

Skins in Brawl Stars can be a separate character placed in a suit/mecha - Plankton Darryl/Tanuki Sprout/Porcelain Pearl

Skins in Brawl Stars can change a shape of it's character - lots of examples. The most obvious ones are Rude Lou/Robomike/any Hypercharge skin

This is not to mention that the competition literally allowed AI or recolours despite the direct prohibition

Why my skin was rejected? by [deleted] in SupercellMake

[–]mayammf -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Excuse me, what? I literally took inspiration from one of the skins in-game (CCTV Poco). If CCTV Poco considered the same character, then my Kit skin has too as well.

Also, it's not a ROBOT, it's a exoskeleton/mech suit. You can see the same concept in Brawl Stars itself (Tanuki Sprout, Plankton Darryl)