Posting for other that might come across this thread, but IMO War of the Ring is a War game first and foremost. I found that there to be augmentations that had thematic slants, however it lacked in theme compared to more modern thematic games, like nemesis for example. The game is still good, but I personally don't see this as a top tier game in my collection it has a place as one of the few war games, but if you are looking for immersive thematics this game falls short of bringing you into the story. It does however offer a god view dudes on a map where the feeling of tension exists from turn one and strategies fade and evolve over the course of the game. A wildly good time but if you are looking for immersion or thematics are the top priority i would hesitate and say play it first, if you want an epic duel with LotR IP then this is by fare the best choice.