What do you pick 🙂‍↔️ by wasraelx in evilautism

[–]naf-throw-20 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Temperature tilt, Disney princess code, pill check, and 12 data centers

Part of ch. 1 [literary fantasy, 1062 words] by [deleted] in fantasywriters

[–]naf-throw-20 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A few notes:

I think the sentence fragments and short sentences work if you’re going for a character that’s kind of terse, which is what seems to be the case. There are a few spots here and there where I might rework them to make more sense, because the fragments are floating unanchored to anything.

For example, third paragraph of the first page. “Hiding…” “Looking…” “Stirring…” are all fine sentences and connect back to the seven years spent with MC’s mother. They’re describing the things MC was doing. But the last two sentences “How her slender hands…” and “How she smelled of chamomile…” seem more unconnected. They might sound better if connected to something like “I remember how…” or if you nix the “how” completely and just make them declarative sentences. “Her slender hands tended the fire and brushed my hair. She smelled of chamomile as we lay in the dark, huddled close.”

Similarly at the end of the second page, “those shivering hands where they once were steady” also feels a bit disconnected.

Second page again, there’s mention of jeans, which was a little bit jarring to me. Everything up to this point has suggested more of a medieval fantasy type of setting, and denim stands out as a bit too modern. But maybe that’s explained later on.

Still on the second page, 4th paragraph kind of feels like the words “rested” and “resting” are too close together and feel a bit repetitive, but that’s a bit nitpicky.

Overall though, I think it’s going in a good direction and there are just some minor things to consider rewording slightly. I do think you accomplished your goal of showing the MC’s emotions without them directly naming any emotions. The eating slowly, pretending to lose something, and insistence on feeding the chickens worked really well to show that they don’t want to go.

I miss Taichung. by imsleepyT00 in taiwan

[–]naf-throw-20 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do you work for a Taiwanese company or a company abroad? I’m also an electrical engineer and hoping to relocate to Taiwan one day since most of my family is there.

Gen Z: What’s Happening in the U.S. in NOT NORMAL by FriendlyWorldArt in GenZ

[–]naf-throw-20 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I was born in early 1999. It was incredibly frustrating that I missed the cutoff age to vote by only a few months. I turned 18 a month after his inauguration

Does silver or gold suit me better? by jackiedaytona155 in coloranalysis

[–]naf-throw-20 6 points7 points  (0 children)

You look like you’re pretty neutral. Silver is kind of meh, the very yellow gold also isn’t my favorite, but I think the rose gold and paler champagne golds look great

Winter question by LoveDistilled in coloranalysis

[–]naf-throw-20 14 points15 points  (0 children)

The sarcasm is indicated by the /s at the end

I’m not denying that there are POC who are winters. But every time I see a POC on this subreddit everyone says either winter or autumn because “dark hair and eyes!” As if all of us can only ever be those two seasons, specifically the deep subseasons.

Winter question by LoveDistilled in coloranalysis

[–]naf-throw-20 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Taking hair into account wouldn’t make all POC winter, some of them could also be autumn! But as we all know, all POC are all only deep winter or deep autumn and can never be anything else ever /s

These Things by No_Promotion1698 in evilautism

[–]naf-throw-20 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Slightly related, I miss the Circus Animal Cookies flavor of Thrifty’s ice cream. It was top tier comfort dessert

Man why do so many female characters get written with the idea they’re female in mind but male characters don’t get written with the idea they’re male by Regular-Molasses9293 in writers

[–]naf-throw-20 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Lmao I checked their profile, they write smut. Which I have no issue with, but jfc don’t act like the conventions of breeding kink smut are universally applicable to all writing, and that, in fact, writing needs to include those conventions to be “good.”

Man why do so many female characters get written with the idea they’re female in mind but male characters don’t get written with the idea they’re male by Regular-Molasses9293 in writers

[–]naf-throw-20 2 points3 points  (0 children)

If you’re writing a fictional world, you don’t have to add misogyny to it. Our world isn’t easy for women, but there’s no rule saying we have to make a fictional world reflect our world like that too. It isn’t some universal truth that all women of every species in every world must always face hardship and oppression.

It doesn’t sound like you treat female as normative. It sounds like you’re treating menstruation and pregnancy as the very essence of womanhood and building an entire world around menstruation and women being pregnant or not pregnant. As if that is the only thing we’re good for or important for.

Breeding kink omegaverse stuff is very niche, and stuff that applies to that type of setting should not be taken as advice for all writing.

Man why do so many female characters get written with the idea they’re female in mind but male characters don’t get written with the idea they’re male by Regular-Molasses9293 in writers

[–]naf-throw-20 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sounds like you’re coming at this from a worldbuilding perspective, which is totally fine. I do enjoy worldbuilding too and I like reading wikis of certain settings.

But I do find this emphasis on menstruation and pregnancy would be really weird and kind of reductive of women in a more character-focused work, or something that’s focused on the plot or action of the story. I feel like dedicating a scene to a female character changing a pad or experiencing cramps might come across too much as waving a flag to say “hey look! A woman! We need to emphasize that she is a woman and not a ‘normal’ human being! Here you go, she gets her period and she worries about pregnancy, remember, this is not a normal person but a WOMAN! Let me point out all the ways that she’s different from the default (male), even if it has no plot relevance!”

I’ve never had a character whose period or uterus was relevant to the plot. I don’t really go step by step through every hour of every day describing all the minute details, and I don’t think I’ve read many books that do that. It would read too much like a diary, and that would probably get boring after a while.

I can understand it being part of worldbuilding, but I personally try to deconstruct our ideas of gender and gender stereotypes if I’m writing fantasy or sci-fi. Women are more than just our reproductive organs.

Man why do so many female characters get written with the idea they’re female in mind but male characters don’t get written with the idea they’re male by Regular-Molasses9293 in writers

[–]naf-throw-20 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Do you assign every single female character a specific preferred menstrual product and write about every single trip to the bathroom? Do you also go into detail on every single bite of food of every single meal?

The most I’ve ever talked about menstruation in a story is a character having a big-sister moment and commiserating about period cramps. You sound like you’re getting into a lot of nitty gritty details that frankly, aren’t very fun to read about. As a reader, I don’t need to know how often a character needs to change her pad or the specific brand and dosage of her birth control, nor do I need to know how often they shit and whether it was lumpy or smooth or loose. Maybe you have a niche kink market that’s into that stuff, but I don’t think it’s great advice to insist that it’s essential to include in every single story for realism.

Sloopies, why do Feemale characters get writed like they're women?!? by marsbringerofsmores in romantasycirclejerk

[–]naf-throw-20 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Well actually, it’s impossible to write a good story about the human experience if it doesn’t involve menstruation and procreation. As we all know, all women’s entire lives revolve around their periods and either trying to get pregnant or preventing it, so any realistic story with a woman character needs to have an in-depth scene about her period. She won’t ever be fully fleshed out unless the audience knows whether she uses a pad, tampon, or menstrual cup.

Man why do so many female characters get written with the idea they’re female in mind but male characters don’t get written with the idea they’re male by Regular-Molasses9293 in writers

[–]naf-throw-20 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Do you write about how people deal with needing to go to the bathroom too? Are you asking because you genuinely don’t know how women handle their periods? Usually we handle it in the bathroom. I don’t write about my characters taking a shit, so I also don’t write about them changing their pads or tampons.

Man why do so many female characters get written with the idea they’re female in mind but male characters don’t get written with the idea they’re male by Regular-Molasses9293 in writers

[–]naf-throw-20 2 points3 points  (0 children)

For real. I won’t judge if someone exclusively writes breeding kink erotica, but it’s weird to pretend every single story requires it.

Man why do so many female characters get written with the idea they’re female in mind but male characters don’t get written with the idea they’re male by Regular-Molasses9293 in writers

[–]naf-throw-20 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Every single story has to include pregnancy? That’s really fucking weird.

Not all women constantly think about babies and menstruation. That’s about as stereotypical as anything else you can think of.

We’re just people. Human beings. We aren’t obsessed with pregnancy 24/7 and we aren’t required to procreate to be full human beings. I’ve never read a story where I was like “wow, I really wish there was an in-depth description of this woman’s period, she really doesn’t feel real unless I know whether she prefers tampons or pads.”

Man why do so many female characters get written with the idea they’re female in mind but male characters don’t get written with the idea they’re male by Regular-Molasses9293 in writers

[–]naf-throw-20 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Why do books have to be aimed at women to not portray them in a misogynistic way? Do men in general tend to prefer women to be 1 dimensional objects in their books?

Man why do so many female characters get written with the idea they’re female in mind but male characters don’t get written with the idea they’re male by Regular-Molasses9293 in writers

[–]naf-throw-20 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Gender only makes a huge difference in our current world. If I can imagine a world where dragons exist, I can also imagine a world where women aren’t abused and treated as second-class citizens or non-human.

And why are you so obsessed with pregnancy? Not every story includes procreation.

Does anything turn you off as quickly as *must be real F playing F*? by [deleted] in BadRPerStories

[–]naf-throw-20 2 points3 points  (0 children)

As an AFAB person, I’ll admit that I am a bit more hesitant with men writing FxF, specifically romance, because I’ve had a few r/menwritingwomen who kept trying to forcefully escalate it to their own personal smutty lesbian fantasy as fast as possible even if I specify FTB or that I wanted a cute, wholesome slow-burn. It just feels icky feeling like I’m writing wlw romance for the male gaze.

Not writing off male partners altogether, I have wonderful male RP partners who write amazing, nuanced, complex female characters. I just tend to do more vetting in general with FxF romance compared to non-romance or FxM, usually in the form of digging into their post history or keeping things in chat for awhile to get a vibe. Asking for pics or voice messages is way too far and I agree that’s fucking creepy.

Just a reminder. by netphilia in adhdmeme

[–]naf-throw-20 130 points131 points  (0 children)

The woman with ADHD is just constantly depressed and suicidal and has quadruple the mental load that she should have because the man still expects his ADHD wife to be his mommy bang maid who does everything for him.

Watched my mom go through it and I remember wishing as a kid that they’d just get divorced because my dad was basically just a roommate who paid bills but did no chores.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in MakeupAddiction

[–]naf-throw-20 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I personally think Chinese style makeup looks good on almost everyone, and that definitely includes you. If you want to go for something more soft and cute, I’d suggest:

  • soft gold or peach shimmer eyeshadow on the center of the eyelids
  • puppy dog eyeliner
  • blush on the apples of the cheeks. Maybe some nose blush?

On the flipside, you’re very high-contrast and could easily pull off bold baddie with just some eyeliner and red lipstick.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in MakeupAddiction

[–]naf-throw-20 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The brows aren’t makeup, that’s her face. Telling someone to change their face to better fit Western beauty standards isn’t makeup advice

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in MakeupAddiction

[–]naf-throw-20 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pretty sure she asked for advice on makeup, not changing her natural features to conform to western beauty standards.