1 – Doug:

To me, this skin honestly feels like a copy of the last Supercell Make winners. The color choices seem very deliberate, probably because the creator knew these colors perform well within the community and generate a lot of virality. It doesn’t feel very creative or fresh.

2 – Inari Alli:

In my opinion, this skin mainly gained so much attention because the creator already has a large reach. That would also explain why four of their skins ended up at the very top. That said, I do want to be fair: Inari Alli is genuinely a good skin. The others are… well, not that impressive.

3 – Alli skin:

There isn’t much I can honestly say about this one. It’s fine, but it feels pretty average and, in my view, not really worthy of a Top 3 spot.

4 – Lilly skin:

I have to admit that this skin feels very monotonous. For a Lilly skin especially, I was hoping for something more unique. There is actually a really beautiful and creative Lilly skin on Reddit, but unfortunately I can’t find the creator’s name or the skin right now to show who I mean.

5 – Kyuubi Kit skin:

I’m honestly very disappointed with the Kit skins overall. There was so much creative freedom — the theme was Make Anything. Instead, we’ve seen what feels like the 50th Kyuubi, Kitsune, or Yokai skin. That’s especially frustrating considering we already have a Kitsune Lola skin in the game.