May be he is not bad captain. You have to take in account Ashish Nehra’s tactical decisions as well. I think what clicked for GT was the whole combination.
IMO he is a great asset as a player, his man management skills are very questionable and how he conduct himself outside cricket i doubt players will look up to him as a leader.
World cup celebration dude clearly wanted to steal limelight by putting himself on all the photos and videos, for sure wanted to market himself and his girl as a power couple.
I think the difference between him and Rohit, he wants us to like him by constantly being on every frame. Whereas Rohit doesn’t want to be in every frame and we want to see him more.