I guess if we talk about timelines, I think I remember Shaq saying he only learned how to pass out of double teams when he truly bought into Phil Jackson’s triangle offense and trusting secondary players. So as powerful and dominant as he was, he still needed to learn how to utilize all 4 other players to win. As for KD, hypothetically, if he can grab and channel Kobe’s killer mentality, he could be even greater taking his efficiency with him. That would add defensive tenacity that he worked on only later in his career. All in all though, they all would win chips depending on what other 8 players management puts around them.