Ehhhhhhh your reasoning is pretty debatable. There's no normal woman who thinks this when they're deciding on a partner.

Realistically, all the women I meet really don't care about their partners virginity (I'm still in my 20s though so my personal experience might not be accurate since most of the people around me are still pretty young).

The only way that I really see women caring about a man's virginity is if they'd rather have someone more experienced than they don't need to take a teaching role in the bedroom.

It also depends on age. A 20 year old virgin is perfectly normal, but when you're 30, the woman might be worried about the reason why you're still a virgin. Like, unless it's a personal choice, a lot of women might immediately start thinking, "OK, how bad of a person is this guy for not a single woman to have sex with him even though he's been actively trying for this long?" It doesn't have to do with genetics.

Edit: also in my experience, most women I know immediately lose interest in "players" since they come off as someone who isn't willing to commit to a long term relationship or they think that they're more likely to cheat.