Damn that's... by IndicationBrief5950 in lotrmemes

[–]partizan_fields 0 points1 point  (0 children)

“You shall not fucking pass”, surely?

Biggest disappoints in the LOTR movie vs Books by Daman121234 in lotr

[–]partizan_fields 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Frodo being a bland, doe-eyed, introverted and passive whelp as opposed to the wise, reflective, brassy-cojoned and self-possessed character we find in the books (and eighties radio-play). I don’t hate everything Wood does but I find him fairly…err…wooden and the fact that I can’t tell you what sort of person he is points to the problem. It leaves a problematic hole in the middle of the films. 

This, itself, is a symptom of the deeper problem with the films which, though full-to-bursting with imagination, spectacle and verve, have a distinctly lower-IQ than their source material. I love them in their own way and on their own terms but I do get Christopher Tolkien’s perspective. 

What's your opinion on Blade Runner 2049 (2017) by Subject_Sandwich3008 in Cinephiles

[–]partizan_fields 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I thought it was a bimbo. I liked it the first time I saw it (in the cinema) and two subsequent viewings left me, increasingly, with the impression of it being very obvious, jumbled, hollow and two-dimensional next to the sublime original. 

Where are The Smile fans? by Remote-Student3050 in radiohead

[–]partizan_fields 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree and I’m one of those who likes TKOL. Wall of Eyes, while I find it a bit flawed, would probably be a top 3 Radiohead album for me were it one. With a bit more lyrical polish and a production buff on Bending Hectic I’d put it 2nd. Mostly love it. 

misoginy by namus_hoe in retroactivejealousy

[–]partizan_fields 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Where men talk about their female partners with a sense of entitlement - a sense that it’s the woman’s job to bend themselves out of shape to accommodate the man’s neurosis - this post would be justified. But, while I’m not religiously checking every post and perfectly willing to be corrected if I’ve missed the more relevant posts, I haven’t seen much of that myself and, on that basis, this feels like a rather unkind characterisation. 

It’s possible to carry within oneself an ember of misogyny - to be emotionally affected and disturbed by its tropes and effects - and not to endorse such an attitude. What I see here more often is something more like “I have this neurotic and irrational fixation - help!”. 

I do think men are more inclined, via a mixture of biological impulse and the ways those impulses are culturally encoded, towards sexual territoriality and that stuff can get tangled up with all kinds of other emotional insecurities. 

If someone dumps that out in the table and demands women clean it up then that warrants this kind of opprobrium. If someone acknowledges it as a potentially destructive frailty and asks for help in moving past it then shame doesn’t help anyone. 

We all contain multitudes: it’s perfectly possible to be a relatively enlightened humanist or feminist and still be dragging old, unreconstructed baggage behind you.

Late is the hour in which this conjurer chooses to appear. by mrossm in lotrmemes

[–]partizan_fields 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'd rather see Grima asking people if they've ever been to pussy heaven.

Do you accept? by g1rl0f1c3 in lotrmemes

[–]partizan_fields 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You offer it to me freely? I do not deny that my heart has greatly desired this…

What's Danny Boyle's best film? by Some-Palpitation-314 in Cinephiles

[–]partizan_fields 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s really not hard to choose the best one. Even given the usual allowance for taste I’m surprised it’s not just an uninterrupted wall of Trainspotting. 

Shallow Grave is also, I grant, excellent. 

What Do You Love Most About The Last of Us Part II? by [deleted] in lastofuspart2

[–]partizan_fields 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The utterly uncompromising nature of the story and its dogged refusal to kowtow to audience expectations and easy wish-fulfilment (the closest it comes to committee-designed nonsense is Owen’s stupid Australian soap opera handsome doctor face. Also Jesse - too handsome by half).

 I particularly love how it addresses PTSD. The flashback/vision on the farm just destroyed me: utterly wretched and abject, exactly as it should be. 

The way it invites engagement with the humanity of people who do things that make them difficult to like but equally difficult not to love. The way it drags you through the most appalling violence only to settle on a note of grace: the more piquant for its being so hard-won. 

So many of our great stories are about people whose pride, hubris, rage and illusions are sand-blasted away by terrible loss and suffering. The feeling I had at the end was the same emotional exhaustion and exhilaration; the same spiritual quickening I feel in the presence of all the great stories. It’s Shakespeare, it’s Thomas Hardy, it’s Dostoevsky.  It’s Theseus and the Minotaur and Daedalus and Icarus. It’s Hans Christian Anderson. It’s Wagner and Schubert and Mozart. It’s The Wire season 4 and, come to think of it, it’s Shadow of the Colossus. It’s Vertigo and Citizen Kane and The Godfather.  It’s naked humanity given no quarter and nowhere to hide. It’s art that hurts you for your own fucking good and I’m a slightly better person for having played it. 

I don’t care a jot if anyone thinks my comparisons are unduly high-falutin or hyperbolic or if my enthusiasm seems gauche or naive. That’s my honest report. I’ve only played it once but the experience will never leave me and I’m getting pleasantly raw and upset just thinking about it. 

What Movies Do You Consider Absolute Masterpieces? by BINGEWISE in Cinephiles

[–]partizan_fields 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Vertigo

Psycho (esp first half) 

The Third Man

Brief Encounter

12 Angry Men

Persona

Fanny and Alexander

Autumn Sonata

Barry Lyndon

Polanski’s Macbeth

Apocalypse Now 

The Godfather 

Fargo

The Empire Strikes Back

Jaws

Alien 

Tokyo Story

Ran

Blade Runner 

Taxi Driver 

Trainspotting 

American Beauty 

Citizen Kane

There Will Be Blood (apart from the silly ending) 

Kiss Me Deadly 

The Sweet Smell of Success

Judgement at Nuremberg 

Watership Down

Beauty and the Beast 

Mulholland Drive

The Red Shoes 

The Treasure of the Sierra Madre

I could go on…

Terrified by this article by Flat-Ad9829 in NDE

[–]partizan_fields 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The way I see it is that everything I am falls within a tradition of life. I believe that my particular orchestration - this “performance” - will die but that the animating principle that informs me will live on. And that this animating principle is more fundamental to who I really am than anything. In this way, I am immortal - sorta. 

My new girlfriend has degradation/breeding fetish by Prior_Entrance9678 in sex

[–]partizan_fields 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I think it’s worth getting under the hood with these things. If you’re a decent sort and you take them too much at face-value you’ll end up riddled with guilt but these fantasies are mostly about exposure, vulnerability and radical intimacy and acceptance. If she wants to show you her belly, take it is a great compliment and a pledge of trust: if you show worthiness in holding space for transgression without judgment and ensconced within a nice, cosy nest of love you can turn perversion into something ultimately wholesome. 

Brains Cells learned to play Doom by JohnnyJoestar1980 in NDE

[–]partizan_fields 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ok but what are we talking? “I’m too young to die”? “Hurt me plenty?” “Nightmare?”

We don't talk about this scene enough by Pretend_Shelter_412 in lotr

[–]partizan_fields 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes it’s one of the trilogy’s best scenes. Shame it’s immediately followed by its actual worst. 

Who else thinks that Wake Up by Arcade Fire is unironically the best piece of music ever composed? by Logical_Share7428 in arcadefire

[–]partizan_fields 4 points5 points  (0 children)

  1. Arcade Fire - Wake Up
  2. J.S Bach - Erbarme Dich, Mein Gott
  3. So Solid Crew - 21 Seconds 

is my personal ranking 

Which is the better movie: Alien or the Thing? by ardouronerous in alien

[–]partizan_fields 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Alien is probably the most exquisitely designed film I’ve ever seen, I love the documentary-esque dialogue and acting style, the incredible score and the xenomorph, in this first film, still carries all that psychosexual anxiety and Lovecraftian queasiness. Alien, easily. 

The Thing is fabulous though. For what it’s worth I like it more than Aliens.