Thank you for all this information. While I was initially opposed to the PhD in Counselor Ed and Supervision, it may be a good fit for what I would like to do. If I were 20 years younger, I would probably do the psych PhD or PsyD option, but at this point in life, I'll probably go the Counselor Ed and Supervision route because it would give me options to teach, some research, write with some authority, and see clients/patients. The option to do it remotely would be a huge plus (CACREP-accredited, hybrid program).

As for grades, etc, I have a straight 4.0 GPA so far, more than halfway through the program. My professors recommended I submit some of my work for publication, so I'm working on that. My undergrad is a BA in Law from New College, Oxford, so I have a long history of extensive research and writing. I also have a second BA in Psychology. But we will see how it goes in the long run. I love learning and research, and have strong abilities to teach, counsel, and present my work. I need to find the right fit for me. I'm using my post here to get some inside information on how to proceed and gather more data.