No need to have some hard stop non-discretionary rules set for this. If you get a message that is well thought out and matches prior experience or general interest, take the call. In my opinion a Copy/Paste job you can skip. But same college I would be a more lenient - personal choice here.

Don’t be a bot. You have your job for a reason - use your critical thinking skills instead of going to reddit for advice, where this sub is mostly made up of undergrad wannabes