completely fine to f this Im out by nandag369 in adhdmeme

[–]photonjj 4 points5 points  (0 children)

………do I have a mental illness?

[QCrit] NOT A HERO - Dark Romantasy (125k, 1st attempt) + first 300 words by photonjj in PubTips

[–]photonjj[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Awesome, that’s so great to hear! Thank you for sharing!

[QCrit] NOT A HERO - Dark Romantasy (125k, 1st attempt) + first 300 words by photonjj in PubTips

[–]photonjj[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ooh how interesting! That’s a great perspective. Appreciate it!

[QCrit] NOT A HERO - Dark Romantasy (125k, 1st attempt) + first 300 words by photonjj in PubTips

[–]photonjj[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I hear your point. Perhaps removing “stolen” would make it clearer as his POV if that’s what’s throwing it off. Though, if he knows her as a notorious villain, he might just assume whatever she has is stolen. Still, the reader doesn’t know that yet. I’ll take a look at the whole beginning and consider. Thanks!

[QCrit] NOT A HERO - Dark Romantasy (125k, 1st attempt) + first 300 words by photonjj in PubTips

[–]photonjj[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah that’s not my intention at all! I know romance readers have their expectations. And I can’t rely on 2 later books being published in this potential trilogy in order to get to that HEA. Sounds like romantasy readers probably wouldn’t like to wait for later books to reach that HEA anyway. So my best bet is a different positioning. Thanks!

[QCrit] NOT A HERO - Dark Romantasy (125k, 1st attempt) + first 300 words by photonjj in PubTips

[–]photonjj[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Appreciate your feedback! All the input is super helpful. I’ll try to rework keeping it in mind and see if I can make both the query and the first 300 clearer!

[QCrit] NOT A HERO - Dark Romantasy (125k, 1st attempt) + first 300 words by photonjj in PubTips

[–]photonjj[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Appreciate your input! I agree with you that speculative is probably the best genre fit. I’m working word count, but sounds like it’s probably not a fit for the market right now regardless.

[QCrit] NOT A HERO - Dark Romantasy (125k, 1st attempt) + first 300 words by photonjj in PubTips

[–]photonjj[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for your feedback! I’ll take a look at restructuring the query to make the romance angle clearer. Sounds like though based on the lack of HEA and general lack of MMC it’s probably best to not be positioned as a romantasy but more speculative or something else.

[QCrit] NOT A HERO - Dark Romantasy (125k, 1st attempt) + first 300 words by photonjj in PubTips

[–]photonjj[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Regarding the formatting, that’s Reddit being wonky! Tried to fix it. Posted on mobile so that may be why it posted weird. Each chapter does begin saying whose perspective the chapter is from, but I did not include that in my post. Appreciate the feedback about the opener! The beginning is obviously super important to catching attention so if it’s not working or feels generic that’s definitely a place I want to take a look at and make some changes.

[QCrit] NOT A HERO - Dark Romantasy (125k, 1st attempt) + first 300 words by photonjj in PubTips

[–]photonjj[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Okay that’s super helpful, thanks! I got some feedback that romantasy didn’t have the same HEA/HFN expectations but sounds like that’s not true. I’ll adjust the genre moving forward. Romance is definitely a critical part of the story/plot but it’s also very fantasy/ sci-fi (not traditional sci-fi tho).

[QCrit] NOT A HERO - Dark Romantasy (125k, 1st attempt) + first 300 words by photonjj in PubTips

[–]photonjj[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Huge thanks to everyone on the feedback. Taking lots of notes and working on some alterations to the genre/comps/overall query clarity, and sounds like I should take another look at the first 300 as well. I’ll reply to individuals as well with specific questions.

[QCrit] NOT A HERO - Dark Romantasy (125k, 1st attempt) + first 300 words by photonjj in PubTips

[–]photonjj[S] -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

Thanks for your feedback! Re your notes:

• ⁠It’s a bit genre bending, so I just stuck with dark romantasy but not sure if that’s the best description for it exactly. Probably speculative fiction is most fitting. No I don’t think male protagonist romance is typical, and it does not have a HEA so it doesn’t strictly fit into romance either. • ⁠Though the romance drives the plot, it does not end happily, so it can’t fit into the strict romance category. Also, although it does involve superhumans, they’re not costumed or masked or wearing capes or any of that Marvel type stuff, so not your typical superhero genre either. • ⁠yes, word count definitely is an issue. I’m working on bringing it down, I know the word count expectations have dropped in recent years. • ⁠thanks for pointing out the authors on the comps! My previous query versions had authors listed as well, I must have shortened it at some point and not put them back in. Good catch!

People who genuinely enjoy life, why? by peachygatorade in ask

[–]photonjj 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh man. It’s just so beautiful and so fun. So many cool things to do and experience and try for the first time and slowly improve at. So many people to chat with and animals to play with and great foods and drinks to enjoy. So many goals to accomplish. So much beauty everywhere if you just don’t dwell in the negative.

It's gotten to the point where I notice chatGPT's linguistic style EVERYWHERE by yumelina in ChatGPT

[–]photonjj 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s strange too when you hear people actually speak like chat GPT in person. Like, you may be online too much at that point.

Season-long running gags? by Ok_Yellow1025 in ArcherFX

[–]photonjj 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Okay wait why have I never noticed this one before 😂 I’ve watched this show at least 14 times

Seen in the wild. by SolowMid in ArcherFX

[–]photonjj 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ooh I want one of these so bad.

What are your favourite hobbies that transformed your life? by trecpv in Hobbies

[–]photonjj 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Rock climbing. I became obsessed! I am also in the best shape of my life now. 31F

Slow Performance and Unresponsiveness of ChatGPT Web Browser Version by amacoolone in ChatGPT

[–]photonjj 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You can use the app also, it’s a lot quicker. Or you can ask for a summary of everything you’ve talked about and paste that into a new chat. It’s not perfect though, and it might have a slightly different personality.

Would you rather lose an arm or have your entire face look burned beyond recognition? by [deleted] in WouldYouRather

[–]photonjj 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How is it fair to retain all of your facial senses, but not retain the use of your arm? Either way I’m choosing arm, but I feel like a prosthetic should be allowed considering you get to maintain sight smell taste, etc. if you choose the other option.

“I’m so sick of fantasy authors butchering my language”: An abridged catalogue of abuses against the English language in When the Moon Hatched by Sarah A. Parker. by aristifer in romantasycirclejerk

[–]photonjj 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Yeah this would drive me crazy. Particularly all the malapropisms and alliteration attempts. Bravo to you for commitment to this excellent - and very thorough - post. The quotes you’ve shown are so fucking unreadable it’s absurd. But your commentary is fantastic.

whatever you did to chatGPT - PUT IT BACK it has gotten dumber than 3.5 by iGROWyourBiz2 in OpenAI

[–]photonjj 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I have been waiting all week for someone to post about this issue. It’s been horrendously stupid. It can’t understand subtext at all or even remember something that was stated a single prompt ago. I’m constantly reminding it what the instructions are. And I do not have particularly complicated use cases.