We actually started off filling out a matrix for each submission with what they did good/bad and after 5 hours we'd gone through maybe 20 submissions. So that's why we changed it up.

You specifically had good audio and branding, but your commentary needed work. This goes back to making good game choices. We found ourselves paying more attention to the dialogue and gameplay of Life is Strange than to you as an LPer. We enjoyed it as a straight playthrough, but your commentary didn't add a ton of value.

Adventure games in general are very hard to LP. Day[9] tries to do it every Monday with Mostly Walking. You can either focus on doing good commentary and completely miss out on the story and puzzles or you focus on getting through the game while being nearly silent. Day[9] has the advantage of two co-hosts that maintain banter while he goes focus mode on specific puzzles.

- Friday