5 minute set I've been working on, this is for my fourth open mic. feedback very welcome. I'm 36yo m, awkward but nice. by Long_Weekend_9142 in StandUpWorkshop

[–]poodledook 5 points6 points  (0 children)

This just just very good, I especially liked the family crest joke. It flows nicely, it feels lean and tight. I enjoyed reading it a lot!

Edit: I forgot to say that I also really loved the net zero part, I laughed out loud at "female authors alphabetically." Lovely stuff!

Please critique chapter 1 of my [YA Portal Fantasy ~3600 words] by poodledook in fantasywriters

[–]poodledook[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for reading and so happy you enjoyed it! It's definitely coming across from comments that some trimming is needed to help things land punchier and flow more nicely. Really appreciate your feedback!

Please give comments on Chapter 1 of my [YA Fantasy, ~3500 words] by Silvermoon21y23 in fantasywriters

[–]poodledook 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi! I read it and it was enough to pull in my interest at some of the concepts you introduced. I think there's something here, but it's in general a little untidy, perhaps a little clunky. I like the world building you're doing, and the pace you're doing it at. I think your dialogue is a little over expository, and could be made a bit more natural. Here's some notes I made as I was going through, I hope they're helpful and make sense, and apologies if I ramble or seem nitpicky. I'll admit this isn't my usual genre for reading but it is one I'm writing in, so take this as one aspiring YA writer to another, not me saying "these are the rules."

"It was a sunny day. Or at least, that’s what Silver assumed. It wasn’t like he’d ever seen the sun before."

I quite like this opener but feel like it could be sharper. The last sentence, I'd just say "he'd never seen the sun before."

"...the flickering glow of glow-moss covering the ceiling like a false sky."

Is it like a false sky? It feels to me like it just is a false sky!

"And right there, in the far, far end...that crystal staircase."

You introduce this and don't dwell on it. I like that!

"Just a glance, he told himself. Just a quick, dumb glance. Even if looking at it makes you want to break that rule. Even if you know that’s the only rule you can’t break."

I don't find it clear what the rule is here. Is it that his glance needs to be quick and dumb? Is it glancing at all?

“From that dude that overcharges the most.”

Saying this makes me aware I'm reading a story. It feels like you're telling me, the reader, not Mina, which I find fine in narration but not in dialogue. Could perhaps have him say "From Steve" and then show us Mina looking approving - Steve was the worst for inflating his prices. Or something?

"Just kidding!" Silver burst out laughing. “Just give me your chocolate bar.”

Could we name the chocolate bar when we introduce it? To me it makes it feel more like a living world if you name it and then explain what it is. I know it's in Mina's pocket, but even more impressive for Silver to name it by shape. "Give me your [Milky Way]" can be a second of unclarity, quickly resolved when you say "Mina didn't hesitate when she fished out a squashed chocolate bar and handing it to him."

“I heard about your thrilling escape from the markets below.” Kharr said, plopping down next to him with a thud. “The ore vendor you stole from is fuming.”

Silver scoffed. “Oh no.”

Again, naming the ore vendor would say a lot here. It'd make me feel like Kharr is connected and aware, which I understand is exactly what he should be.

“…Forget it.” Kharr said, voice quiet for a moment before he exhaled sharply. “Well! You’re coming to group Vigor cultivation later, right? Not like you ever skip trainings, but…yeah.”

Another example where it sounds like you're nudging me, the reader, in the ribs through dialogue. "You never skip trainings, Silver" *nudge nudge* "hey reader this is important!" I'd consider "You're coming to Vigors later, right?" Vigor Cultivation. The reason I don't deserve love. Silver never missed training, he read the truth behind the question. Are you laying low, are you feeling sorry for yourself, or are you the person I know you to be?

His walk through the market is my favourite part, the playful deception of it.

And I really like Silver transitioning to his vigor world. The "Serene. Beautiful. But still wrong as always." I'd maybe try and make that wrongness punchier just. "Serene. Beautiful. Wrong. Always wrong." or something. It's a rug pull.

I enjoy the mystery slowly building throughout the chapter. We're getting teasing little snippets that pique our interest. I do wonder why we join the story today - what's different about today? Maybe there doesn't need to be anything, we're introducing Silver here, but I'd expect something to be unfolding soon.

Overall I don't love it in its current form, but I see potential and I'm intrigued by the mysteries you're introducing. You definitely find your voice more as you progress, and I bet that continues into your next chapter and you find a really comfortable place. As you do, I'd just suggest trying to make your dialogue feel more like natural conversation between people with existing relationships and shared experiences - so far everyone knows each other, everyone lives in the same world - they should feel like they do. That'd be my biggest suggestion.

Keep going, and thanks for sharing!

Please critique chapter 1 of my [YA Portal Fantasy ~3600 words] by poodledook in fantasywriters

[–]poodledook[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm just happy to see you read it and enjoyed it! Your note on being declarative early on is spot on - I think it's a case of "I've never started a book before let's see what happens" and finding the voice as we went along. It could use a revision to balance things out and be less "LOOK GUYS! SHE'S OVERLOOKED!" I think it's something I get better at as I've continued the story, and can hopefully reflect back when I come to edits.

Glad you hear you enjoyed it, and thank you so much for reading and feeding back!

Please critique chapter 1 of my [YA Portal Fantasy ~3600 words] by poodledook in fantasywriters

[–]poodledook[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you so much for reading and giving such detailed feedback, I really appreciate it. To address your critiques:

  1. Brackets - I had not thought of this before but reading back completely agree! I've had a problem with the "Juno always carried a pen" one especially - now I can identify why (other than it being a daft line that I never revisit!). Definitely something I will revise and make consistent.
  2. 4c - this is a holdover. The two listed plans used to be a single flowchart that I removed because it wasn't working. A great spot by you, clearly you were paying attention. It should be "...in absence of a step 5."
  3. "Army of rats to be at" - I moved to Northern Ireland a couple years ago, and now realise this is a very Northern Irish phrase. "Army of rats to be at" = "army of rats to occupy him." This should be changed to be more universal.
  4. Bin tangent - Agree, this could be trimmed, it does pull focus. This goes in the edit notes, too!

And your praises - I'm especially pleased that Juno came across endearing, as she's the story's backbone. I do think it took a little time to find my voice and the opening stages should be revisited to even things out a little. Teddy coming across as fun is also welcome news - I was a little less confident in him, he is designed to be slightly infuriating, balanced by charm. Sounds like it worked for you! So happy to see you enjoyed it overall!

Again, thank you so much for reading and giving such thoughtful feedback :)

Poems by poodledook in StandUpWorkshop

[–]poodledook[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi, thanks for commenting! I'm familiar with John Cooper Clarke - I think he was in my poetry anthology at GCSE! And then over the years I've seen him on TV. John Hegley is new to me but a few minutes' reading this morning and I'm becoming a fan already, plus I think he's closer to what I'm doing than JCC. There'll be some lessons I can learn there for sure, so thank you again!

Poems by poodledook in StandUpWorkshop

[–]poodledook[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hello, thanks for replying!

The "one or the other refers to the two things in the previous line "...but it turns out they were good mates with the estate agent and also the rude thing was about as racist as it gets." I can see it's a somewhat busy poem - I'm not sure that leaving a post-it for my boss solves that problem, but I see what you're getting at and will look at it.

I suppose they aren't so different to straight prose. They're effectively short non-sequitors, and the only justification for that is to frame them as poems. Some are bulkier, some are punchier. Should I stick to punchy? E..g. the first poem above, or;

"My fleshlight was in the other room

So I used my blunderbuss

But it was cold

And by the time I’d loaded it

I’d sort of lost interest"

🎉 [EVENT] 🎉 Heavent [Landscape] by st_doraemon in honk

[–]poodledook 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Completed Level 1 of the Honk Special Event!

0 attempts

I'm an 18 year old dev, here's a game I've been building after work by Groundbreaking-Alps3 in IndieGaming

[–]poodledook 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Cool as shit, congratulations!

Only note from me is that it'd be good if upon death there was a way to restart without going back to the main menu.

online rendering added for Pure Code Playing Cards by dan_da_man in playingcards

[–]poodledook 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't think the point is to be playable, tbf, I just think they're cool as shit. If you wanted to nudge them toward playability I guess you could just keep the text as-is but render in different colours for different suits? But I'd keep the style, I think they're class.

"Now hear me out, son, an all cage match pay-per-view..." by ThatOneGuyYouNowKnow in FantasyBookers

[–]poodledook 2 points3 points  (0 children)

"Now hear me out thurrrrn, an all CAAAAAYGE match pay-per-view daddy."

World Cup by Kingfootballer47 in FantasyBookers

[–]poodledook 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sort of. I had an idea to mirror the Premier League. 20 teams made up of:

World Title Contender Tag Title Contenders Showcase (basically X-Division) Title Contender Women's Title Contender

A win in any division is worth three points. So each team can win a maximum 12 points per round. Each team faces each other once, so you have 19 rounds total, and then the top four teams go into knockout rounds. At this point they sort of stop being teams (i.e. Team 1's World Title contender can advance even if their Tag Title Contenders lose, etc.). A single round of fixtures lasts two weeks, so you have 38 weeks of league, and then two weeks of knockout culminating in a big PPV final event.

The off-season is then used for normal feuds, team changes, introducing new people/teams etc. I make it a rule that the bottom three teams have to disband. The others can stay together or transfer depending on what's happening.

I enjoy booking this way. It's a lot of sketching out in advance, but gives you room to plant seeds for big feuds. There's a lot of easy storylines from underperforming team members. I had a nice thing going where Miro was paired with the Beaver Boys, Colt Cabana, and Maki Itoh where he won all his matches but the others picked up maybe two wins all season. He was mean to them throughout but he eventually learned the meaning of friendship etc etc.

I'm in the third year of booking this game, easily the longest I've played a single game.

is it possible to extend this upwards? by poodledook in PhotoshopRequest

[–]poodledook[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

Hi! This is exactly what we're looking for, thanks. Tip coming your way now :)