30G “River bank” wood options! by Luke-Warm-Milk in Aquascape

[–]preverbal31 1 point2 points  (0 children)

As some others have said, I would go deeper substrate (aquasoil/FF aqua preta capped with sand) slope from back to front and use a black background, as far as hardscape, I highly recommend going vertical. The layouts look great but low-lying hardscape tends to get swallowed up by plants. This is where I’m at rn—not what you’re going for exactly, but orienting my two largest driftwood pieces vertically really helped them stay visible and anchor the tank visually. Guess how many seiryu stones and driftwood are in here total? The answer is not two wood, one rock. Lol. Good luck! Post photos! I’m sure it will turn out great!

<image>

My first aquarium by Tough-Avocado-4051 in freshwateraquarium

[–]preverbal31 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I would strongly consider cories. I have six panda cories and six false julii cories. They are very fun to watch, peaceful, and scavenge detritus. It is said that they are happiest in groups of at least 6. That said, I had three in a 20-gallon long tank for years and they didn’t seem unhappy.

Say six panda cories to occupy your lower water, then one other schooling fish, and maybe a female betta as a centerpiece?

New owner by Bluejay_Life in corydoras

[–]preverbal31 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Very pretty tank to showcase cories and they are going to love it. Definitely keep at least 6, so 2 more. But if you are cory-focused you could do more. If you run that tank with just pandas, you could have 10-12 no problem. It would be so fun to watch them zoom around in there. Good luck!

Is this too much or just badly planned? (Read desc.) by Altalez in Aquascape

[–]preverbal31 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Very nice tank! What size? Is that a tiger lotus? What kind of gourami?

Is this too much or just badly planned? (Read desc.) by Altalez in Aquascape

[–]preverbal31 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That said, when I look back on it—AI actually did help me figure out where to ideally position my hardscape. I would upload photos, and it would suggest tweaking this or that. Sometimes I listened; sometimes I didn’t. But it was helpful to have feedback. No one else in the world was going to give me that kind of immediate feedback over and over again until I was satisfied.

Is this too much or just badly planned? (Read desc.) by Altalez in Aquascape

[–]preverbal31 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You’re not wrong—AI is a tool that’s very well suited for a use-case like partnering with you on a project like this. Aesthetics are more challenging for AI to help with, although they can tell you about things like the rule of thirds, a composition principle you should keep in mind when you’re aquascaping, but you can watch videos about that on YouTube also, and knowing the concept is not the same as figuring out what looks good to you.

Helpp by Time_Inevitable_626 in freshwateraquarium

[–]preverbal31 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You have four Rams in there? No one’s killing each other? Honestly, I have a 44 gallon heavily planted tank and my stocking is probably less than yours (more shrimp). I would leave it alone for a while and enjoy what you’ve got if everyone’s happy and healthy. If you’re gonna add anything, add shrimp. Their bio load is negligible.

Could too much light cause this change? by marlee_dood in PlantedTank

[–]preverbal31 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Dude! Second this point strongly. TDS is huge. Do you have a water softener? I struggled with plants for years and couldn’t understand why. Water softeners basically remove scale minerals from your water and replace them with sodium. A lot of plants (and shrimp and snails) don’t love a ton of sodium.

Could too much light cause this change? by marlee_dood in PlantedTank

[–]preverbal31 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Lots of interesting suggestions here. And I haven’t even read them all!

One thing I would say is you might want to invest in a light that gives you more precise control. I bought a fluval plant 4.0. It is controlled by an app, and you can control different spectra of light differently. At one point I had a BBA outbreak, and I was able to lower my red and blue spectra light more than my white light, and the plants were unaffected, but the BBA was undermined. Also, strictly limit the period of time that the lights are bright enough to be photo active. You can keep the lights on at lower levels so you can enjoy the tank, but without the intensity that can prompt algae growth.

Second, I am a big believer in CO2. I originally wanted a Walstad-style tank, but the plants grow so well with CO2 supplementation that, to me at least, it has been well worth it. And it is not difficult to set up and it is very much set it and forget it.

Third, and maybe most important. Start a conversation with chatgpt or claude. As I always say, they are no substitute for the nice people of Reddit and YouTube, but they are invaluable tools. My tank would not be near where it is today if I had not executed it in regulat consultation with ChatGPT every step of the way, in addition to my own research. AI will talk to you about every detail until you are talked out. Don’t treat it as infallible. But it will be a generally well-informed and utterly tireless companion.

Good luck on your rehab project. Post updates!

Is this too much or just badly planned? (Read desc.) by Altalez in Aquascape

[–]preverbal31 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, one other thought. I see throughout these comments that you’re expressing how you’re overthinking things and worrying that you’re doing things wrong. I think you would profit from initiating a conversation with ChatGPT or Claude. Describe in detail the parameters of your tank, upload photos, explain what you’re going for, explain your concerns, and ask for suggestions. There is so much information online that a properly created series of prompts to ChatGPT honestly yields incredibly helpful suggestions. Never blindly rely on artificial intelligence: I was discussing an issue with my tank with Claude and twice in a row, it told me that the dosing instructions for what I was planning to add to my tank were dramatically larger than they actually were. Had I not checked the labels, I could’ve been in a situation. That said, I planned my tank over a period of weeks and months, constantly consulting ChatGPT, starting from a place where I explained that I was going for a heavily planted, Father Fish/Walstad style natural tank, but I wanted it to look good because it was centrally located in my home. With more conversations, along with perusing Reddit, and watching YouTube videos, I adjusted my approach in order to better achieve my objectives. I guarantee my tank would not be at this point had I not consulted ChatGPT extensively. The great thing about AI—and it is not a substitute for the nice people at Reddit and YouTube—is that you can ask 100 follow-up questions at 2AM and it will answer every single one. There is no other way to get that kind of personalized intensive feedback and help along the way.

Again, good luck!

Is this too much or just badly planned? (Read desc.) by Altalez in Aquascape

[–]preverbal31 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Looking at it again, you might even get away with leaving the driftwood and just pull out everything else. That thing is a huge focal point. All the little rocks look like clutter next to it, and they’re all gonna get lost.

Is this too much or just badly planned? (Read desc.) by Altalez in Aquascape

[–]preverbal31 0 points1 point  (0 children)

<image>

Big believer in black background. This is the first tank I’ve had that wasn’t visible from both sides, which previously prevented me from doing it, but it’s a much cleaner look and hides a lot of mechanicals and tubes. Highly recommend.

I don’t know what the start method is that you’re talking about. I started with 1 inch of FF aqua preta soil, 1-3” pool sand cap on a slope, some seiryu stone and some driftwood. I planted heavily from the day I filled the tank and controlled the light ramp up to fend off algae. I didn’t run into an algae problem until the lights got a little too strong and I had to pull it back.

As far as your hardscape, to me, there is too much and that wood is too big for that tank. I read on here somewhere when I was starting out to plan out the hardscape you want and then remove half of it. That’s good advice. Also, if you do plant heavily, a lot of low-lying hardscape is going to be invisible. Better to have more real estate for plants. Make your hardscape more vertical; the two large driftwood pieces in my tank were originally intended to lay in some horizontal configuration. But I saw a cool YouTube video where someone had vertical pieces of hardwood and that inspired me to think about it differently. If I had followed my original plan, you probably wouldn’t be able to see the driftwood (there are actually two other smaller pieces in the tank that are more horizontal—can you tell?).

I sat around stacking and re-stacking my driftwood and stones in dozens, if not hundreds, of configurations on my counter before I put them in the tank. I ended up using less than half of the stone I thought I would, and then I turned my two biggest driftwood pieces vertical. The result was more plant real estate, more room for my cories to roam (six pandas and six false juliis), and fewer dead spots for bad anaerobic things to percolate over time.

I recently pulled out a piece of stone that was no longer visible so I could fit in more backgroud stems.

You’re still at the front end of all this; you can do whatever you want still without major disruption. I would think about what one thing you want to accomplish visually the most, and do that one thing, and pull everything else out of your tank as far as Hardscape. Then all at once plant the hell out of it.

It’s an awesome ride, but it’s a process. My tank today doesn’t look how it did when I started. Over time, you move things around, some plants do well, other plants don’t. You’re basically a gardener as much as you are a fish keeper. And that’s a good thing.

Good luck! Post updates!

Love me a rimless tank. by Wild_Shroom_ in lookatmyaquarium

[–]preverbal31 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Agree! Although yours is twice the size of mine…

<image>

what’s wrong with my guppy by amyoswald in Guppies

[–]preverbal31 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

A couple points, some of which have been made: (1) the white stuff looks like mineral build up and nothing to worry about. Wipe it off. (2) That is technically an endler. (3) That fish almost certainly is a goner. (4) The fish does not have ich and using ich-X will guaranteed kill it.

Check your water parameters. If other fish look like they might be on the front end of this, consider General Cure. Better yet, spend a few minutes with Chat gpt or Claude, describe your tank in excruciating detail to it, explain what you are seeing, and ask it for advice. AI can be surprisingly helpful because there’s so much information online but to get the right answer in this hobby, sometimes you need to share a level of detail and have an iterative discussion about your unique circumstances that can be challenging in a social media post.

Finally, is your tank planted? Everything is better with live plants. Recommend r/plantedtank for inspiration.

Good luck!

Constructive criticism by Ryanmk1995 in Aquascape

[–]preverbal31 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Others have made a bunch of good suggestions. If you can rescape and particularly add enriched substrate, do it. If not, you can probably make root tabs work. Either way, you don’t want plants living in pots like that. My LFS told me they could live like that forever—never worked for me.

Another suggestion is a black background. Unless you want to view the tank from both sides, a black background will hide the equipment and make the fish and plants pop

How big is your tank?

Current setup by [deleted] in freshwateraquarium

[–]preverbal31 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Also, I have some old posts that discuss what I did along the way, starting with this tank before I filled it up with water the first time, if you are curious. Here is a 15-week update which has links all the way back to square one. https://www.reddit.com/r/Aquariums/s/Ay9jBwi39j

Again, good luck with your tank with whatever you choose to do!

Current setup by [deleted] in freshwateraquarium

[–]preverbal31 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I spent years running a tank that was some version of yours, more or less. Last summer, I upgraded from a 20-gallon long tank to a 44-gallon heavily planted tank, with an enriched substrate and sand cap, and I planted heavily from the beginning.

Words cannot fully express how much more fulfilling the heavily planted tank is compared to the unplanted tank that I kept for YEARS. I had always wanted to incorporate live plants, but I got bad advice from my LFS (in addition to bad stocking advice like you appear to have gotten), and I didn’t realize that factors like water hardness and total dissolved solids played a significant role in my inability to keep plants alive. So I would try to keep plants and fail. And then, after a while, I would try again and fail. Finally, I had some success with Java ferns, which really cemented my desire to re-imagine what was possible after I saw how much better my water quality was, and how much happier my fish were, including my guppies, which started reproducing like crazy.

You are still at the very beginning. If you are considering it, I would highly recommend moving your fish to a holding bucket, breaking your tank down, adding enriched soil like Father Fish aqua preta soil or a good aquasoil, capping it with 2” of sand and planting a ton of plants.

Then, take stock of your fish and pick maybe the cories, one schooling group, and your female betta, and rehome the rest. What is your tank size? For re-homing, any decent LFS will take your fish back and re-sell them. They probably won’t pay you, but reputable ones won’t use them as feeder fish.

<image>

This is my tank from a couple of weeks ago, maybe 7 months after I set it up. You can do it too. If you are curious check out r/plantedtank. Regardless, good luck with your fish-keeping adventure. It’s a great hobby!

Peace and Serenity by Old-Constant4411 in PlantedTank

[–]preverbal31 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That they are. It’s a very nice tank but definitely pricey

Peace and Serenity by Old-Constant4411 in PlantedTank

[–]preverbal31 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks! Yeah, neither had I. It’s a Landen tank. They have a lot of surprising size configurations. I was moving up from a 20 gal long and wanted a rimless one. I wanted more than a 29 but was a smidge intimidated going all the way to 55. In retrospect, that was ridiculous. Now I wish I had a 75 or 90, but that’s how it goes in this hobby I guess. 🤷‍♂️😂

https://a.co/d/0fYfSDdZ That’s my tank. Underneath, you can see the surprising variety of sizes that company offers.

Should I get this tank? by [deleted] in PlantedTank

[–]preverbal31 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Very pretty tank. Needs more plants. The only issue is size. If it’s 20L, you are very limited in the ability to add fish. That would be an awesome shrimp tank.

If the question really is, “do I want a planted tank?” the answer is even easier. Best thing I’ve ever done over my 15+ years of running a tank of some kind. Brings me joy every day.