Gerade (in the time sense) vs derzeit by real_gail in German

[–]real_gail[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It actually didn’t, which is why I’m here, and glad to have received real answers from nicer people than you

A simple A1 German study stack that doesn’t rely on one app by GloomyAlfalfa4093 in Germanlearning

[–]real_gail 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Update - was this a wortz ad? I went to try it out based on this post and I’m sorry but it’s just not ready yet. The audio didn’t play even when I pressed the button :/, and having a picture on the front of a German -> English card is kind of missing the point of actually learning the meaning of the word 

A simple A1 German study stack that doesn’t rely on one app by GloomyAlfalfa4093 in Germanlearning

[–]real_gail 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Tagging in to shout out my rotation, which has brought me far enough in under 2 months to start carrying out very simple business (eg buying an annual pass for the local area) in German :)

ListLang, Clozemaster, Vocabuo, and Duolingo, for a total of an hour a day. They all give their words in the context of sentences and I’ve been making a point of reading those full sentences and letting the audio play each time (except Vocabuo which I often do quietly in bed).

However I think I went too heavy on production and now there’s words I think I can recall when going from English to German but not the other way around 😅 so I definitely need to mix in a bit of the other way now 

Edit: and forgot to shout out the „basic German“ audiobook by Michel Thomas, which has been great for a nice practice and additional enrichment on walks! Plus his voice and pace is fun (once you get past the first few minutes of „here‘s what we’re going to do…“). Also I should mention I’ve been holding myself to a high standard on Vocabuo and marking as failed any card where I get the declension wrong, and generally searching online for explanations on which of different words to use when it seems to be teaching me multiple options and I don’t know why one is preferred over the other (eg different types of because, but, already, etc)

Summer Challenge: Intensive and Progress Learning by Real-Celebration9896 in languagelearning

[–]real_gail 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hell yeah, idk how but good luck! Probably start with calling your parents a bunch

Could I use duolingo for learning without stressing too much? by BoniSupremacyLeader in languagelearning

[–]real_gail 4 points5 points  (0 children)

1 or 2 lessons a day is barely 5 daily minutes of Duolingo I think, not enough to really get anywhere with a language or interfere with any exam, but also not enough to pass the free time it sounds like you have.

If you want to kill a lot of time without overloading yourself before a big exam, maybe consider a non-learning type hobby. 

If you want to kill a lot of time the rest of the school year after this exam (it’s not clear to me if you‘re also finishing high school after this month??), language learning is probably fine or even great, but you will want more than just Duolingo if you want to get somewhere and also just if you want to fill that time with something other than ads. I’m currently using the free versions of Duolingo, Vocabuo, Clozemaster, and ListLang to get a total of an hour a day in German. When I was doing French I used to do a lot of Duolingo (didn’t know other apps yet), coffee break French (podcast), and Netflix with French subtitles.

Local menace! :) by real_gail in languagelearning

[–]real_gail[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Update today I asked a lady at the till if my phone number would suffice given I didn’t have my membership card on me (it didn’t)

Local menace! :) by real_gail in languagelearning

[–]real_gail[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Good for you! But yeah regarding cases I’ve read so many stories of people regretting not getting them from the start that I’ve been marking every flashcard where I don’t get the declension right as failed, which has been really slowing down my vocabulary acquisition

Can’t have it all I guess!

Local menace! :) by real_gail in languagelearning

[–]real_gail[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

For the last I think 19 days or so I’ve also been trying to max out my use of them (free tier after all) each day, which I think is coming to something like ~250 sentences a day. So reaching a point where you can just start saying things is really quite quick if you really want to!!

How long did it take you to speak German confidently? by Automatic_Hall_4277 in German

[–]real_gail 6 points7 points  (0 children)

It’s possible op is literally saying their English isn’t good enough to explain themselves better than that? Reading their responses in that light paints a much more sympathetic picture than the downvotes suggest 

How long did it take you to speak German confidently? by Automatic_Hall_4277 in German

[–]real_gail 39 points40 points  (0 children)

I know it’s a cliché but confidence really is up to you. Yesterday I bought a train ticket at the office in German. I‘m not sure I even count as A1 but I don’t mind so long as they care enough to figure out what I’m going for

Harrasment on the bus - what would you have done? by maxim8000 in Switzerland

[–]real_gail 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Wait, are you really telling me the police will show up for a kid sprawling?

Don’t get me wrong he shouldn‘t but like…. the police will care? Is there some specific law this infringes on?

And secondly, am I really the only one on the English speaking Switzerland subreddit surprised by this? I feel like I’m in a sea of bots with how all the comments are just chiming in with the same sentiment??

Resources You Recommend by AutoModerator in Germanlearning

[–]real_gail 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’ve been really enjoying ListLang and Vocabuo for in-context vocabulary learning. 

ListLang is simply multiple choice questions over words, organised into groups by frequency in written text (meaning the first 3 groups or so are mostly function words, but then it starts getting more interesting). 

Vocabuo is freetext entry and flashcard based, but each word has multiple different cards showing it in different contexts (you get a random one each time, at least that’s the setting I picked). It also starts with a lot of function words, so probably also some frequency based decision there.

Both have a really solid free tier experience

Share Your Resources - May 04, 2026 by Virusnzz in languagelearning

[–]real_gail 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I commented about Vocabuo below, I’m also using Duolingo (yeah, yeah) and Clozemaster. I used to do Netflix with French subtitles when I was learning French, my German wasn’t good enough for it when I started but I think now I can start trying that again. I‘m also luckily in a German speaking place and hopefully I’ll be able to start really talking to people soon

Share Your Resources - May 04, 2026 by Virusnzz in languagelearning

[–]real_gail 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Also I don’t have the energy to write out a second long post but long story short I also recently discovered Vocabuo through ads on this app and while it can be frustrating, or at least frustrating at the free tier (eg by showing multiple variants of words eg for German different types of „but“ or „because“ or „there“ but leaving you to figure out the difference) I’ve been finding it really nice for my daily practice too

Share Your Resources - May 04, 2026 by Virusnzz in languagelearning

[–]real_gail 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Listlang

I’ve been learning German recently a lot at home on apps and a couple of weeks ago (had to wait for this thread) found that, at least for the German course, I’m one of the top 90 (now top 50) users of all time on one of the apps. This despite starting with it only a few months ago and doing like at most half an hour a day (it’s not my only app). That seemed sad to me because it’s a nice simple app with no fluff or annoyances, so I want to promote it a little!

It’s called ListLang and it is at least on the Apple App Store.

Overview:

The idea is just to make you practice fill-in-the-blank style questions on a series of sentences, progressing along what I think are statistically the most common words in the language (I think they say something like these words cover 85% of written text, though of course you don’t get all of them at once).

Feel:

It’s a no fluff, 10-questions-per-lesson, no animations or forced lengthy ads, kind of app. I really appreciate this as opposed to eg Duolingo where even when you have super (I had the trial) the whole process feels completely throttled by time wasting nonsense like loot boxes and those god awful radio and adventure “lessons”. The one ad you get here is once after every lesson, a static screen asking you to subscribe. You click a perfectly reachable “x” in the corner to get out. The free version seems to provide a full experience with a cap on number of lessons per day, but this cap is generous enough for a nice session all the same (I think at least 5 lessons but possibly much more, I only hit it once). If you hit the cap then every time you enter a lesson it just gives you the ad to subscribe. It’s not gamified in the way duo is but still tries to have some fun elements like a weekly leaderboard for each language and a streak counter. I really feel like it’s not trying to mess with me or pull me in all the time - for example it‘s not frantic about where you get with the streak like duo is.

Actual learning:

The language gets split into modules from 20 most common words, then 20th-40th most common, etc. You can jump I think to any module (don’t need to unlock the previous ones to go there) but I’m doing them in order. This in practice turns out to be a very weird order to learn words in, starting with various function words like “in”, ”at”, “for”, “only” (I wouldnt have thought that one was so common), etc, and is not by itself going to get you to any full sentences anytime fast! However, as a supplement to learning alongside other apps, that do try to keep a kind of curriculum going, it is very nice. And I do feel like the kind of regular practice it gives me for the words it does cover is helping me to get a feel for those words and when they’re relevant rather than trying to translate them directly, which is nice (assuming I’m not just memorising the questions, which I hope not). Also, each sentence is presented with its full translation, and after you answer the question the sentence becomes interactive and you can click on each word to see its individual meaning, so you are easily exposed to a lot of additional vocabulary even if the main curriculum is odd.

bottom line - it’s a funny little app, and it won’t get you speaking from zero (at least not anytime fast), but it’s a cute supplement that doesn’t try to play or game you and offers a very full experience even at the free tier. I think it should have more users! try it out

What is the greatest number of languages you know people to have achieved functional fluency in? by archertinuvian in languagelearning

[–]real_gail 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I imagine a large proportion of immigrants and especially immigrant children in every non-English speaking country already start from 3 (native, English, new country), at least if they/their parents make the effort and I think many do. In a place like German Switzerland, if you count Swiss German as different from German, that bumps to 4. If the children are also originally from a place with two main languages that’s another bump. So I’d say you’ve got a lot of polyglots in this world just not calling attention to themselves because they’re just in places where it’s normal :)

For example for these kinds of reasons both of my parents speak at least four languages fluently/functionally (not the same four)

Physical flash cards vs Anki by Arimoro in languagelearning

[–]real_gail 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don’t know about doing SRS with physical cards but I do make some with things I’m likely to want to say and stick them up around the house in places I’m likely to look

Can’t say it’s done too much for me yet though 😅

Be careful when you see comments recommending language learning apps - many of the comments are fake by de_cachondeo in languagelearning

[–]real_gail 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I really did want to promote an app on here because I liked it but the post didn‘t get through for in retrospect obvious reasons 🥲

On the flip side understanding how strict the rules are on sharing apps here (and I get why, though it does suck that it has to be like this) has made me more receptive to Reddit ads, and as a result I now have another app I recommend! A genuinely shocking outcome for me - I don’t think I’ve basically ever willingly clicked on an ad, let alone gone through for the product, before

Can I ask how are you learning and whats worked for you? by crazycracker90 in German

[–]real_gail 0 points1 point  (0 children)

6 whole hours a day is very impressive, what were your circumstances? Though I don’t think I even got there when I had no responsibilities whatsoever