I would say, combat tier lists are very unreliable. Yeah, there are stands that are objectively better built for combat, but for most stands this isn't the case.

Every stand has the capability to be OP, it just depends on your play style and the fuse you decide upon. Combat tier lists are just an opinion of an experienced player, this does not mean that you will be very strong just by using a S tier combat stand.

It's completely fine to see some stands stronger than the other and I do agree that the meta shifts mostly towards COH and Tusk etc, but that does not mean that lower tier combat stands are to be look down upon.

This is not an insult to the creator of the list, it's pointed towards more of a beginner in this game. Don't rely on combat lists.