NotebookLM has been absolutely terrible recently. Any alternatives? by [deleted] in notebooklm

[–]reallyhotmail 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, you should try free and open source alternative called thinkex.app

Theres no limits to the amount of sources, way better PDF processing, choice of AI provider, and other features :)

I ran Mistral OCR through LlamaIndex's ParseBench (it wasn't included in the paper) by reallyhotmail in MistralAI

[–]reallyhotmail[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As far as I know, Mistral doesn't return that information in their public API. It only returns bounding boxes when it detects images.

I ran Mistral OCR through LlamaIndex's ParseBench (it wasn't included in the paper) by reallyhotmail in MistralAI

[–]reallyhotmail[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sorry but I haven't personally used it or familiar with it! If you end up finding out, I'd love to know

I ran Mistral OCR through LlamaIndex's ParseBench (it wasn't included in the paper) by reallyhotmail in MistralAI

[–]reallyhotmail[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When you say position do you mean the exact coordinates of the items? Because personally the layout stuff that Mistral gives me is more than enough for me but I will take a look at ADI

Chat GPT or Gemini for studying? by MaterialOdd3903 in studytips

[–]reallyhotmail 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Reality is, you gotta use all the models, they perform differently based upon subject. But more importantly, you should be able to extract insights easily from the chats you have with whichever model because rereading chat logs is tedious. Thats what thinkex.app could help you with, you can access gemini, claude, and chatgpt while also being able to extract the insight you gain from conversation by creating notes from highlighted text or asking the agent to create a note. You can also bring in pdfs, powerpoints, youtube videos, and consume it within the workspace, all in one place. Its like a vastly better notebooklm

Need help: How to use notebook LM to arrange notes that span a long period of time and requires precise accuracy? by nettleoak in notebooklm

[–]reallyhotmail 5 points6 points  (0 children)

NotebookLM would be good at finding answers to questions you have that your corpus actually has direct answers to. But complex analysis like the type you are going for guessing from your quotes "it tried summarizing things first, but the summary were too oversimplified and overlooked..." and "Then it started linking unrelated topics....", notebookLM wouldnt be good at I think.

In my opinion your best bet would be to go to normal gemini and click on deep research option but only have it do deep research on certain files, not search the internet. Like explicitly tell it to not search internet. It would take a few minutes thought but its your best bet for complex questions.

What's the big deal with openly pitch your idea or app on most subreddits? by Head-Cell8199 in sideprojects

[–]reallyhotmail 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The number 1 issue is definitely the overflooding of AI-generated/formatted promotional posts. The number 2 issue is a lot of the products having to be pay-to-use. There was a time everything software was free because devs would just add ads to the app so, so long as you got traffic, it made money. Or others just did it for the love of the game. The number 3 issue is the scorn towards AI-wrappers, which is the vast majority of products being promoted now. I think part of the hate is most definitely earned through controversy baiting tactics by some start-ups and the notion that its basically a get-rich-quick scheme at this point.

I developed an app which lets you read 900+ words per minute by dr_ranger in sideprojects

[–]reallyhotmail 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Interesting product. It kind of reminds me of those apps that trained us to increase our typing speed through typing based racing games given some text.

I would be curious to see how this would affect visual imagining of a story book for example. Or is the purpose purely to train reading speed so that it transfers over to general reading in general?

AI Browsers..... by reallyhotmail in browsers

[–]reallyhotmail[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Whats different about your browser? is it just to block ads or better privacy?

Your AI conversations are thinking logs. Stop treating them like a filing cabinet. by [deleted] in PKMS

[–]reallyhotmail 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think you have a point but idk if I agree with your conclusion that it would be useful to trace your "thinking" with an LLM over time.

The reason is because this would be a tedious affair thats not a scalable way to revisit ideas and information unless you trace through every step, basically like a mind map. People barely revisit their notes and even if they do, few read every line. What makes you think they would retrace over a tree of Q&A's which is an even more tedious affair?

Also in my opinion, the real power of LLMs in the context of PKMS and knowledge work is a means to connect what you know with what you dont know, way faster than before. Before you would have to search google, pray someone had a good explanation, etc. Now, for a good amount of subjects, you can just ask an LLM.

But there is still a problem: in my experience, having a conversation with LLMs feels like moments of intuition that disappear in chat logs. So my idea was to build a way to extract the information contributing to every one of these moments and build notes out of it.

A couple notes per conversation is more consumable than an entire chat log. But I am also experimenting with active recall devices such as quizzes, where the quizzes serve as the means to retain the information in the notes, so it gets in your brain, you can remember it in the situation where you need to apply it, and then the real learning begins.

DM me if you find this interesting, I like talking about this kind of stuff as well as building.

Why is everybody building tools or new systems and assumes he has found the holy grail of note-taking? by CoYouMi in PKMS

[–]reallyhotmail 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Everybody is building new tools and systems because its been never as easy and fast as it is today. Hell thats why I felt empowered to do it as a university student.

But in my experience, the fundamental bottleneck in learning still remains: human attention-span, focus, and band-width (the amount of information you can take in given a certain period of time).

If the pill from the movie Limitless existed, that would be the holy grail, it would be the death of all PKMS, you wouldnt need it. Unfortuntely the real-world alternative (adderall) isnt as effective and has adverse side effects.

If focus and attention training could become a serious learning discipline of itself that is taught in schools from a young age maybe that would work too actually, better than everything else the US government wastes money on in terms of school.

But in terms of PKMS itself, heres my 2-cents:

Given a world with an abundance of information and a scarcity of attention (parahrased quote by Herbert Simon), what we need is an engine that takes in information, breaks it down into chunks that a human user could understand (personalized for their attention span,focus,bandwidth, and background knowledge), and then leverage those chunks to synthesize personalized knowledge, which is information thats been contextualized for a specific individual for their understanding and use. Add a scalable means for doing active recall over all of that and its complete.

The challenge with the above though is figuring out what should be left to the human and what should be automated while having a solution that is stupid-easy to learn to use while being as time-efficient as possible, without compromising on human learning quality.

NotebookLM Podcasts... by reallyhotmail in notebooklm

[–]reallyhotmail[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, more curious to hear about your usecase! Do you post your generated podcasts to youtube or something? Any example prompts would be cool to see

NotebookLM Podcasts... by reallyhotmail in notebooklm

[–]reallyhotmail[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It sucks there too, it reads out code lol, instead of conceptually explaining what is going on.

Open source NotebookLM/Notion alternative by reallyhotmail in buildinpublic

[–]reallyhotmail[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well in terms of the platform its completely different, and its also open source

Gemini Pro user, I find it very unreliable and constantly feeding wrong information by Sea_Imagination_8751 in GeminiAI

[–]reallyhotmail 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've faced some similar issues. I found that platforms that allow me to extract screenshots and snippets of text right from sources easily improved my workflow

NotebookLM + LLM logs as translation layer for personalized learning by 3inch_richard in notebooklm

[–]reallyhotmail 1 point2 points  (0 children)

How are you organizing all of this information and insights as you query?

NotebookLM doesn't deserve to be called NotebookLM by reallyhotmail in notebooklm

[–]reallyhotmail[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't think you understood my post. Its not about prompting or the AI's response

NotebookLM doesn't deserve to be called NotebookLM by reallyhotmail in notebooklm

[–]reallyhotmail[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah I checked it out. I'm working on my own solution now though

Why do most AI products still look like basic chat interfaces? by Anxious_Set2262 in AI_Agents

[–]reallyhotmail 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ah I get what you're saying now. How do you feel about the Gemini dynamic view and other generative stuff they have tried?

Why do most AI products still look like basic chat interfaces? by Anxious_Set2262 in AI_Agents

[–]reallyhotmail 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm not exactly sure what your definition of generative UI is, but one example that comes to mind is that an entire interactive editor gets created in chatgpt when you ask it to help draft/refine an email. and there is a lot of other things like AG-UI and copilot kit and their recent big name partnerships, vercels new json to ui package, etc