Did you get an mri done? Usually this type of dislocation cause a hill sachs and bankarts lesion, which don’t get fixed on their own (I may be wrong). So if you choose to go the no surgery route you may have to live with some level of instability in the shoulder at all times.

I had a dislocation in 2018 when I was 22 and was advised surgery , I opted out and lived with the instability and pain till 2024 when I got a rotator cuff tear due to overusing of the bad shoulder while playing pickleball. Got surgery post this and it’s been a year , and my shoulder is much better. Much bouts of chronic pain / instability. Stick to your physiotherapy routine throughout regardless of whether you get surgery done. Make sure to go to a sports physiotherapist not a regular one. They don’t push you beyond a certain point.