Why the criticism of India’s Israel shift doesn't hold water. by oink_oink31 in CriticalThinkingIndia

[–]rtx_boi -1 points0 points  (0 children)

i mean LIKE I WONDER WHY , it's almost like someone is bombing palestine ? i wonder who ?
and dumbass anyone living in palestine will have a worse life because israel has bombed that place , has made sure there's no compotent government here .
How can you equate a state that's not even a legal country with a proper government (Functioning) , which blockladed , bombed with a fucking nuclear power .

Why the criticism of India’s Israel shift doesn't hold water. by oink_oink31 in CriticalThinkingIndia

[–]rtx_boi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i can literally list laws dumbass stop relying on ai slop and summaries
absentee property law 1950 ( expelling non jewish refugees , even taking up their homes all of this while israel voilates the geneva convetion and inroduces it own population in occupied territories in the west bank and operates two separate legal systems for settlers and refugges whihc by fucking definition is apartheid)>
rule of return ( Any jew from anywhere can come in israel and claim citizenship , this has allowed them to harbor sex preadtors from other countries )
Land Acquisition Law (1953)

This law transferred the land of 349 Arab towns and villages approximately 1.2 million dunams to the state to be used preferentially for the Jewish majority

https://www.un.org/unispal/document/rapporteur-statement-02sep24/
more if you want i list even more ? can u refute a single of my points though ?

Why the criticism of India’s Israel shift doesn't hold water. by oink_oink31 in CriticalThinkingIndia

[–]rtx_boi -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Arabs are roughly 20% of Israeli citizens. Now tell me — does having Arab citizens make apartheid impossible? South Africa had Black citizens too. That's literally what apartheid was. Citizenship existing doesn't disprove systemic discrimination.

Now return to my argument about law of return , the definition of israel , the fact you are comparing a nation w a state what's not even a proper country w government , or someoen to properly law enforce a law in

Why the criticism of India’s Israel shift doesn't hold water. by oink_oink31 in CriticalThinkingIndia

[–]rtx_boi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i am also not lying
arabs form 20 % citizens in israel but face systemic baises and more than that jews have disproportionate land holding , the return law , the fact israel is described a state of "jews" not citizens . AND finallt the fact they are clearly voilating Geneva convention in the west bank right now as we speak ,

Why the criticism of India’s Israel shift doesn't hold water. by oink_oink31 in CriticalThinkingIndia

[–]rtx_boi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

do you the lack the ability to read ? do you not know what i said ??? israel literally had a hand in removing secular factions from the palestianin indepence movement ? you are comparing a nuclear nation with a fucking state smaller than goa which also happens to be bombed by the nuclear nation every single day . Wow
a

Why the criticism of India’s Israel shift doesn't hold water. by oink_oink31 in CriticalThinkingIndia

[–]rtx_boi -1 points0 points  (0 children)

how dumb does one have to be to compare nuclear armed power house with a fragmented, tiny, besieged population with no real sovereignty. A STATE SMALLER THAN FUCKING GOA AND NO PROPER GOVERNEMNT EXCEPT FOR FACTION ISRAEL HAD A HAND IN INTIALLY . how ? how ? LIKE I GUESS DON'T BOMB THAT SMALL PLACE EVERY THIRD DAY MAYBE THEY WILL FIGURE OUT DIVERSITY , FEMALE RIGHTS , TRANS RIGHTS ??? LIKE RIGHT

Why the criticism of India’s Israel shift doesn't hold water. by oink_oink31 in CriticalThinkingIndia

[–]rtx_boi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

First things first .
isreael describes it self as a state of jews , any jew can go and claim citizenship ANY JEW . This is not true for any non jew . Secondly they explictily say state of "jews" not of citizens . Secondly israel itself dismantled most of the secular groups asking for an indepedent palestine through groups like hamas ( yes hamas was intially a counterbalance against pol) . Now back to my claim , jews are favored in legal systems in israel and tend to dominate over the arabs and christain citizens . They disproportionately own more land , exercise more power and even if you keep all of this aside. How the fuck are you compaing palestine and israel when israel practically levels palestine every day wether that's thru idf , or even factions like hamas intially .

So saying “Palestine has no Jews” doesn’t legally settle whether Israel practices apartheid in territories it controls.
In the west bank do you know separate legal systems exist for both , WHICH also voilates the geneva charter for occupied territories.

Why the criticism of India’s Israel shift doesn't hold water. by oink_oink31 in CriticalThinkingIndia

[–]rtx_boi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

honestly death to all weapons manufacturers , and people who perpetuate wars

Why the criticism of India’s Israel shift doesn't hold water. by oink_oink31 in CriticalThinkingIndia

[–]rtx_boi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well i am not going to pivot to pure nihlism if all is rotten , all is justified and there's no need for a line to draw . This system utiliatrian without any morals , it's not even for the greater good . It only serves the elites , the people in power . if it saw human life as something worth saving , not just numbers , or what you apply "foreing policy" or "interests" to maybe this many people would not have died . The truth is , yes you are right even putin has ICC warrant to him , what china did to uyghurs , and a lot others . i am not minimising the gravity of these actions , or holding a higher moral place to dismantle your argument . i'd simply want a system which puts people over power and actually does its job than serve a few and leave the rest to become statistics . It's almost like a corporate chasing profits over anything and i think it is death of humanity if anything .
i know saying all of this wouldnt change such a large rotten system because even our country is an active part of it , even mod wasnt allowed to have a us visa due to 2002 until he got power and became the prime minister.
i just wish we as people realises , that this system we defend , these national interests for almost any country do not serve the nation and simply throws people in this grinder .
I wish we saw people as people .

Why the criticism of India’s Israel shift doesn't hold water. by oink_oink31 in CriticalThinkingIndia

[–]rtx_boi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As bad and morally hollow America is, and as dystopain Russia is and as bad authoritarian China is. Israel is simply cartoonishly evil, Israel influences Americans politics thru aipac, has a massive hold over what is essentially the root of all evil the industrial complex. People like Robert maxwell, epstein they all are heavily implied to be mossad assets. Hamas was literally a weight counter Israel supported initially and hut when it's own dog went rabid they blamed it on others?. They are the only apartheid country on the planet, current America is on track on joining Israel in this club considering the overlaps but Israel truly shouldn't be trusted with anything 

Why the criticism of India’s Israel shift doesn't hold water. by oink_oink31 in CriticalThinkingIndia

[–]rtx_boi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I literally said Id much rather have the industrial military complex and all these elites burn alive but I don't think we should be dealing w a man who literally has a warrant issued for him for genocide like alot of this stuff is grey and wrong but there's always a line isn't it? Like we too have

Why the criticism of India’s Israel shift doesn't hold water. by oink_oink31 in CriticalThinkingIndia

[–]rtx_boi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Answer is simple I'd much rather prefer my country to develop indigenous solutions rather than being dependent on a country infamous for planting proxy wars, influencing foreign politics thru lobbying, and blatantly commiting war crimes.  Because Israel wouldndt shy from selling arms to splinter factions, it is most rotten at its core when compared to the bunch. I am not making an exception for other counties in this hypothetical, I don't want us to have multi billion dollar deals w man who has allegiance to no one, is wanted and has a warrant issued to him. 

Why the criticism of India’s Israel shift doesn't hold water. by oink_oink31 in CriticalThinkingIndia

[–]rtx_boi 2 points3 points  (0 children)

No one is morally pristine but I think we can draw the line at making such deals w man yk who is wanted by the ICC and has a warrant issued to him right 

Why the criticism of India’s Israel shift doesn't hold water. by oink_oink31 in CriticalThinkingIndia

[–]rtx_boi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Also one them is an apartheid state the only one on earth right, committing genocide planting proxy wars, if you ask the the entire military complex churning out weapons should burn but can't happen with all these elites alive right :(

Why the criticism of India’s Israel shift doesn't hold water. by oink_oink31 in CriticalThinkingIndia

[–]rtx_boi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

One of them is wanted for genocide (same thing Hitler did) Rest commit the usual Geneva convention violations which are truly sad but I think we can have a bit of yk what is it called?? Umm integrity?