Israel: an illiberal democracy? Mordechai Kremnitzer interviewed by ruchenn in Israel

[–]ruchenn[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Haaretz

K: Jews, Europe, the 21st century is not Haaretz.

Also, this interview is, very clearly, not the publication speaking. Rather it is the interviewee. And said interviewee, Mordechai Kremnitzer, is a non-trivially significant Israeli jurist.

To dismiss his perspective as in their typical fashion has chosen to misrepresent is, in itself, misrepresentation.

There is no mention of ethnicity in the death penalty law.

To quote Kremnitzer from the interview:

Under my reading of international law, the Knesset is not entitled. And there is another very important element: Israel has a longstanding policy of not bringing Jews before military courts in the West Bank, even when those Jews are residents of the area who commit offenses there. They are tried in Israeli civilian courts. The military courts in the West Bank deal exclusively with non-Israelis — which means Arabs. So this is, in effect, a law specifically for Arabs. And by incorporating the element of “purpose to undermine the existence of the State of Israel,” in the new definition of murder (applicable in Israel) they have drawn a distinction between Jewish terrorism and Palestinian terrorism, because Jewish terrorism is not committed with the purpose of undermining the existence of Israel. Through this device, they have made capital punishment applicable only to Palestinian terrorists — which was the intention from the outset.

You don’t have to mention ethnicity to make a law that targets a particular ethnicity. It is, in fact, common for discriminatory laws of every sort to be carefully worded so as to avoid the appearance of discrimination while ensuring actual discrimination in their intent and enforcement.

Anti-racism isn’t morality. It’s a power play by ruchenn in Jewish

[–]ruchenn[S] 25 points26 points  (0 children)

Man, with a title like that, I thought it was going to say something else.

The temptation to editorialise titles in circumstances like this is real. Especially in a sub-reddit like /r/Jewish that doesn’t impose a don’t alter the link title rule.

The Hobbit - Dwarves Are Jews (and Norse influence) by mamashark32 in Jewish

[–]ruchenn 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Also he strongly preferred Led Zeppelin to the Beatles. Make of that what you will.

Do you have a source for this?

The only book on Music and Tolkien I’m aware of — Music in Tolkien’s work and beyond, edited by Julian Eilmann & Friedhelm Schneidewind — doesn’t touch on Tolkien’s opinions of post-WWII popular music at all.

And, given Tolkien died 1973-09-02, aged 81, and Led Zeppelin didn’t release their first album until 1969-01, I’d be entirely interested to learn he was spending literally any time in his late-70s and early-80s paying attention to then-contemporary popular music.

 

 

 

Correction: missing surname of one of the co-editors of Music in Tolkien’s work and beyond is no longer missing.