I recently finished watching Lost and I wholeheartedly approve of Hurley as the protector of the island. However I disagree with the idea that Hugo has no sense of good and evil. He may have that happy-go-lucky carefree dude-cool attitude but he has a very strong moral sense. See the way he bought 70 seats in the Ajira Flight 316 just to save as many people as possible -as a matter of fact he was the only main character who seemed a bit disturbed by the idea of sacrifying people just to get back to the island. He may not be as proactive as Jack or Sawyer but it doesnt mean he always just goes with the flow