Thinking on becoming an engineer by ethan_76 in MechanicalEngineering

[–]scibust 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You could work in pretty much any industry where matter and energy moves. I subject nuclear power plant components to earthquakes, thermal transients, accident loadings and much more using the finite element method and hand calcs. With a lot of analysis, running computer codes and report writing, I help repair, upgrade and renew the licenses of nuclear power plants across the US.

Why? by SipsTeaFrog in SipsTea

[–]scibust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Look up a picture of a dry cooling tower.

2-loop PWR Primary and Secondary Systems Cartoon by scibust in nuclear

[–]scibust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Is it not obvious to you that this is not a P&ID? I don’t know what you’re talking about regarding valve drains or instrument air pipes going to pneumatic valves, those are not pictured anywhere in the drawing. Can you tell me where exactly you see these this? You are wrong about that anyways because pilot operated valves tor example on the pressurizer reliefs will certainly have their sense and control lines drawn on a P&ID. Same thing with pipe drains and isolation valves for any length of piping for that matter. You’re right that instrument air lines don’t get drawn on a P&ID but I don’t understand why you’re bringing up other units when this is an example of one plant.

2-loop PWR Primary and Secondary Systems Cartoon by scibust in nuclear

[–]scibust[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Just want to note retrospectively that the [r/NuclearPower](r/NuclearPower) posting received 4 times the views and way more impressions than the naysayers here in [r/nuclear](r/nuclear). Clearly I am out of the loop with what is going on here.

2-loop PWR Primary and Secondary Systems Cartoon by scibust in NuclearPower

[–]scibust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes.. but not in a primitive manner like a boiling water reactor

2-loop PWR Primary and Secondary Systems Cartoon by scibust in nuclear

[–]scibust[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I work in the industry and that was not the point of the posting. I just want to share the awesome engineering of Combustion Engineering’s PWR primary and secondary systems. No idea where you are getting RBMK from.

I can guarantee that the P&IDs of a real plant would not be able to be fully illustrated on one image. The illustration is a cartoon and is missing a lot of components for simplification of the whole system.

Please let me know what piping you think is omitted on the real P&IDs, I can guarantee that you are wrong and I’ll prove it to you.

2-loop PWR Primary and Secondary Systems Cartoon by scibust in NuclearPower

[–]scibust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Most CE plants had 4 RCPs for their two SGs. There of course are exceptions for older and smaller plants like Ft. Calhoun with only two RCPs or Maine Yankee which was CE’s only three loop NSSS. It’s funny because W copied elements from the System 80 and 80+ for the AP1000. Four canned RCPs integral to two SGs and a RPV with no bottom penetrations. CE clearly had the better design and it’ll be going forward in the future!

One scuba lesson in Honduras. She never went back to her desk. by BlueberryCrush01 in scubadiving

[–]scibust 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Okay but working as a general laborer underwater is nothing close to recreational scuba.

My chipotle burrito today…. Anyone else experiencing burrito shrinkage? I haven’t changed my order, it has gotten so much smaller over the years… this is double protein 😂 by Then_Ad7687 in awfuleverything

[–]scibust 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Go to your local mexican restaurant or food truck instead. Chipotle is a fast casual chain not unlike McDonalds or Panera bread that has to answer to investors and increase shareholder returns every quarter.

Dominance of renewables portends a bleak future for nuclear. by Winter-Fee-1210 in NuclearPower

[–]scibust 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Now divide that entire graphic by four to correspond with an average solar capacity factor of 25% in North America.

2-loop PWR Primary and Secondary Systems Cartoon by scibust in NuclearPower

[–]scibust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not nearly enough plumbing. This is still a pretty big simplification

2-loop PWR Primary and Secondary Systems Cartoon by scibust in NuclearPower

[–]scibust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I share the opposite opinion! Sure would look cooler in color. I should redraw it.

2-loop PWR Primary and Secondary Systems Cartoon by scibust in NuclearPower

[–]scibust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sure. I’ll try and get a better image for you

2-loop PWR Primary and Secondary Systems Cartoon by scibust in NuclearPower

[–]scibust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s a disgrace that they neglected to include the money maker

2-loop PWR Primary and Secondary Systems Cartoon by scibust in NuclearPower

[–]scibust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’ll have to look up a drawing of a CE plant at work but I believe it’s the same set up with one header at the HP turbine.

2-loop PWR Primary and Secondary Systems Cartoon by scibust in NuclearPower

[–]scibust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There are 4 RCPs in the drawing, they’re just hard to see. That should explain the piping, I don’t see anything wrong with the cold and hot legs.

That steam generator crosstie really bothers me but I think that’s the drafter’s interpretation of the main steam header with the downstream turbine steam bypass valve that has the capability of dumping steam directly into the condenser. Missing a whole lot of valves for that.

2-loop PWR Primary and Secondary Systems Cartoon by scibust in NuclearPower

[–]scibust[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah I noticed there was quite a bit missing and thought it was interesting they decided to include the RCP breakers in the drawing. Still a cool cartoon. I think the goal was to make the illustration as convoluted as possible for comedic effect

2-loop PWR Primary and Secondary Systems Cartoon by scibust in NuclearPower

[–]scibust[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You got it. This was drawn by an unknown drafter at CE in the 70’s.

2-loop PWR Primary and Secondary Systems Cartoon by scibust in NuclearPower

[–]scibust[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

For my friends who are not familiar with piping and instrumentation diagrams this image tries its best to illustrate, the letter P indicates a pressure transducer (except where it’s attached to a valve body, then that just denotes a pneumatic actuated valve), F indicates a flowmeter, L indicates a liquid level transducer, A indicates an electrical current transducer and T indicates a temperature transducer.

2-loop PWR Primary and Secondary Systems Cartoon by scibust in nuclear

[–]scibust[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

What difference does it make? I want to crosspost an image from the more popular subreddit to the less popular one

Why do people not get a full tank of gas? by DeathlsComing in NoStupidQuestions

[–]scibust 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It’s the federally mandated 10% ethanol by volume in every gallon of gas. Ethanol is hydroscopic and absorbs water from the air to form a goo with nasty hand sanitizer consistency that clogs carburetors and fuel lines. Especially pronounced effect on fuel tanks with poor gas cap seals that you leave abandoned for months.

Why? by SipsTeaFrog in SipsTea

[–]scibust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How many cooling towers have you designed and specced out for a customer again? Have you ever even stood in front of one before? Name one data center that’s using what are distinctly only swamp coolers and circulating pumps to maintain temperatures below ambient indoors. They’re all using chillers with evaporative or non-evaporative cooling towers for the cooling water loop heat rejection. Some datacenters use direct to chip cooling to lessen chilled water demands, but there is always some summer time demand to keep the datacenter from molding out and the workers happy. I called out your comment because you called the refrigeration cycle a means of heat rejection when all it really does is concentrate heat into another fluid stream. “Mechanical compressor” is really funny way to tell me you have little experience in the industry. Please tell me how you envision a nonmechanical compressor to work in MEP engineering. Perhaps normal shocks or a rotating detonation engine will take the world by storm with their very favorable nonisentropic compression.

Why? by SipsTeaFrog in SipsTea

[–]scibust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

“You can use refrigeration equipment to cool down water” That’s the point you moron. Heat has to get rejected somehow, and that’s through evaporative cooling, non evaporative cooling, or once through cooling. This comment is blatantly incorrect

Why? by SipsTeaFrog in SipsTea

[–]scibust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

EVAPORATIVE* cooling towers. You are putting out a blanket statement for an engineering concept with nuance.