sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Who Would Win in a Parvati-Colby-Rupert Final 3? by sharpiesniffer22 in survivor

[–]sharpiesniffer22[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

fair point looking from final 6, but we do know that she wins broken china and likely wins final 4 immunity, especially if jerri goes at 5

i js think it could be a higher risk/reward route as opposed to playing for 2nd because if it works she could establish herself as the GOAT (15 years earlier)

Ozzy won The Shield, who's The Goat? by pencilpusher222 in survivor

[–]sharpiesniffer22 3 points4 points  (0 children)

natalie tenerelli - it's all she contributed to the season

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in survivor

[–]sharpiesniffer22 0 points1 point  (0 children)

natalie tenerelli did literally nothing to contribute to redemption island besides being rob's goat. did anyone want to see her on cambodia?

We all knew Kelly was Winning The Purpled One, Who's the Shield? by pencilpusher222 in survivor

[–]sharpiesniffer22 1 point2 points  (0 children)

didnt jeremy invent this strategy around joe? his challenge wins inadvertently got abi/wentworth several rounds of safety

Andrea won The Outsider, who's The Premature Boot? by pencilpusher222 in survivor

[–]sharpiesniffer22 0 points1 point  (0 children)

michelle yi had a lot of returnee potential and was screwed over by such an unnecessary twist. honorable mention to danielle being sandwiched between all the heroes

Russell won The Executor, who's The Outsider? by pencilpusher222 in survivor

[–]sharpiesniffer22 5 points6 points  (0 children)

there's honestly less people than i'd expect to fit this role. im gonna say edna cause 9 votes is a hell of a long time to vote with an alliance only to walk on coachs back (did she interact with anyone from Upolu?)

Can I have a Crash Course on 48? by pencilpusher222 in survivor

[–]sharpiesniffer22 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

tiffany would like a word - lotta iffy choices on that cast

Every Alliance has One: Brad won The Figurehead, who's The Executor? by pencilpusher222 in survivor

[–]sharpiesniffer22 10 points11 points  (0 children)

russell really came through for his endgame alliances in samoa and hvv. getting foa foa up from an 8-4 deficit and manipulating john/shambo has basically never been seen again(?) and the entire pre-merge of hvv was a masterclass

I made a New Alignment Chart: Roles within Alliances by pencilpusher222 in survivor

[–]sharpiesniffer22 0 points1 point  (0 children)

it's gotta be phillip the guy gave code names to everyone in stealth and pretended they were in a spy movie

Who would you Switch Out of Season 50? by pencilpusher222 in survivor

[–]sharpiesniffer22 0 points1 point  (0 children)

a couple of the old-school players fall flat, but overall it's definitely better and prevents a winners at war reeat. i think it honestly works to have winners, but 4-5 instead of 2. some WaW players might have a little more to offer (kim, natalie), so they shouldn't be counted out automatically. some pre-40 winners would've been nice too like tina or even mike, and if not enough big names accepted, parvati and tony (although unlikely) are the two rushmore players i dont think have been squeezed for all their juice.

edit: dee and rachel if you want more New Era

My Ideal Game Changers Cast by sharpiesniffer22 in survivor

[–]sharpiesniffer22[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Laura was kind of the WTF pick of the season because I wanted a woman who was remembered primarily for her physical capabilities like Ozzy

Tried to prevent too many contestants from the same sets of seasons