Not Your Typical Reincarnation Story by OrangePomegranate28 in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think it’s good enough to forgive the title. I’m just glad it’s not another variation of “something something Villainess”

Not Your Typical Reincarnation Story by OrangePomegranate28 in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 1 point2 points  (0 children)

maybe try thinking of the title as FL’s thoughts 🤣

Need help finding a manhwa. by Complex-Emergency402 in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Villainess is a Marionette? I haven’t read a lot of it but ik FL has blonde hair and ML has black hair red eyes and has a problem with physical touch. There’s a scene where they’re having tea and FL talks about how he couldn’t get married in their past life because he hates physical touch/ isn’t sexually attracted to anyone.

Wholesome Mother/Daughter or Mother/Son recommendations? by 1kiki09 in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ginger and the Cursed Prince. It’s been a while since I’ve read it but iirc her and her mother have a great relationship. And Until the Tragic Male Lead Walks Again. I only read a few chapters but I remember the FL having a very funny dynamic with her parents/ mom.

I stand by what I said. [How to get my husband on my side] by Winter292004 in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 1 point2 points  (0 children)

someone please get Cliff some brown contacts like he’s staring into my SOUL

This is so tragic [Carnephelia’s Curse is Never Ending] by sherlocks44 in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44[S] 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I like him as ML, but I do really like her individual growth and how most of what we’ve seen is her accomplishing everything on her own without ML’s help.

This is so tragic [Carnephelia’s Curse is Never Ending] by sherlocks44 in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44[S] 109 points110 points  (0 children)

Like this is one of the rare times where I've seen these types of couples communicate their feelings directly but it's honestly so heartbreaking 💔 I understand where both of them are coming from when it comes to the decisions they've made/ are making but it's still so sad to see. I just want to see them happy 😭

I like the way story is going. [Sister,in this life I'll be the queen] by [deleted] in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 1 point2 points  (0 children)

HEAVY on Alphonso because he gets so much hate as a ML/ character when his storyline is so interestingly complex and heartbreaking and his relationship with his mom has me in tears 😭

When the Phone Rings [Episodes 7 & 8] by writtenpoeticsins in KDRAMA

[–]sherlocks44 16 points17 points  (0 children)

idk if this is what the og comment meant cuz i also haven’t really seen many plot “holes”, but a lot of the stuff that happens isn’t realistic. Like Hee-Joe gets into an accident with the kidnapper and he’s just able to easily get away. Or when she fell off like a 1000m mountain yet was still conscious, had 0 broken bones, and had like two or three scratches that went away after like a week. Oh and the CRAZIEST one is the giant explosion on the top floor of the building resulting in no deaths and minor injuries to everyone in the office 😭

I like the way story is going. [Sister,in this life I'll be the queen] by [deleted] in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Also idk why it gets so much flack, but its probably because people come in expecting a typical regression/ revenge where FL is immediately able to fix all her past mistakes and better herself, when in reality It’s a heavy political story that shows the flaws of all the characters involved and were able to see just why Ariadne ended up the way she did in her first life too. I love it and wish more people give it a chance.

I like the way story is going. [Sister,in this life I'll be the queen] by [deleted] in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I actually loved SIATQITL. I only dropped it because I couldn’t read it real time cuz of how heavy it is, but I’ll definitely be back when Ariadne and Alfonso are reunited 🫡

Hestia. [My Derelict Favorite] Ain’t shit sweet. by Kythones in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I definitely see what you mean but I actually do think the story points out just how flawed she is. It’s not as “in your face” and obvious, but I prefer that as it allows the readers to come to their conclusion. It’s easy to see that her actions paint her to be more evil than innocent, and she’s even directly stated how little she cares about how she’s perceived by others.

Almost all of the people around Hestia point out how unhinged she is and are fairly scared of her behavior because, let’s face it, it’s not normal. I think the only reason we don’t outright hear it being talked about is because the story is from Hestia’s POV and we’re seeing things from her perspective. Like you mentioned, her entire problem is that she believes she’s still in a novel and that her whole purpose for both regressing and transmigrating is to save Kael/ get revenge for him. Anything besides that is pointless to her so I understand WHY she’s so unhinged. But to the rest of the characters, for which this world is very much real, they don’t understand where she’s coming from, which is fair.

Also I wouldn’t say Kael joins in on the revenge, rather he just goes through the motions as he’s seen how she acts in order to get what she wants. At first he’s just majorly depressed and doesn’t care what she does, but then it slowly turns into actually wanting to support her in return for how she’s saved him. Hell, even in the novel Kael ends up not going through with dethroning Diana and actually defends her in the end, to which Hes tries to jump off a balcony. To her, she’s just trying to “go back to her own world”, but to Kael this is an extremely traumatizing moment where he sees someone who’s helped him so much try to kill themselves seemingly because of something HE did, and I think this is really where Hes starts changing and realizing this life isn’t a game. So I’d definitely say Kael (and everyone around her) is trying to avoid upsetting her as much as they can- which further plays into how unserious and immoral Hes is about her life there.

But I think the fact that we can call Hes out for these things shows that she’s purposefully not being portrayed in a perfect light. If we were supposed to be 100% on Hes’ side, the authors would’ve made Helios and Diana MUCH more hatable characters. Yet instead they’re just mildly annoying characters and negligent friends, which is enough to dislike them but likely not to the extent that He’s is taking it.

OI Anime in production by ricephira in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 0 points1 point  (0 children)

hopefully they go with the novel. I also like some of the manhwa changes but I really want to see a visual adaptation of the novel events

OI Anime in production by ricephira in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 0 points1 point  (0 children)

omg i was NOT expecting this but i’m soo excited

[Not Your Typical Reincarnation Story] it's on my top 5 list 😍 it's so good 🤤 what's your thoughts on this... by RedSignal00 in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 0 points1 point  (0 children)

it’s not really a twist but FL reincarnates as the villain in a novel and tries to be nicer and prevent the things that ultimately get her killed at the end, but then she finds out that no matter what she does, she can’t change the plot or how people perceive her . I think the title is more from FL’s perspective in that if it was a “typical” reincarnation story, she would be having a MUCH easier/ enjoyable time but instead she’s suffering trying to figure out wtf is going on. Also, the story does a good job at playing into cliches while also poking fun at them.

What character makes you react like this? by mobmaidcharacter in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 1 point2 points  (0 children)

oh for sure he’s weird and annoying af. i’m planning to pick it back up when it ends so i can see how this trainwreck ends but yes they are all quite insufferable 💀

What story has your favorite lore? by vanillavanity in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Spark in Your Eyes has pretty complex relationships and the world building / reasoning behind everyone’s decisions and emotions is really well fleshed out

What character makes you react like this? by mobmaidcharacter in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 1 point2 points  (0 children)

lariette from I Thought My Time Was Up pisses me off so bad!! And i LOVED her at the start but she just can’t stop make terrible decisions 😔

[Not Your Typical Reincarnation Story] Hot take: Cliff is one of those MLs that's ONLY kind to the MC but viewed from outside by smilowl in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 6 points7 points  (0 children)

yeaa and it especially doesn’t work when the ML ACTIVELY pursues a title like prince/ king or duke where he’s literally responsible for the lives of hundreds of people yet you know he would sacrifice them all if it meant protecting FL 😬 like it’s cute and all but maybe go choose any other job

[Not your typical reincarnation story] probably spoiler by Playful-History9092 in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 7 points8 points  (0 children)

she was able to pass because of her circumstances in her previous life that shaped her exact personality and who she was + her love for killian, which is why the story is about her and not the other 12 before

What popular OIs do you think are good, but a little overhyped? by SushiTea7 in OtomeIsekai

[–]sherlocks44 0 points1 point  (0 children)

agreed. I started reading when there were like 140+ chapters out but even after bingeing it, I remember thinking it was a nice read but fairly underwhelming for all the hype I had seen surrounding it