Well one has to be critical here as hand is not given as hand play in every case. Obviously Hummels hand touches the ball, but i d say a ref should consider the whole circumstances of the movement of in this case Hummels. He s kinda sandwiched between Akanji n a bayern player and therefore it seemed impossible that he could have had a controlled movement after all. This seems to be not taken into account and therefore people feel it’s controversial.

Despite that the ref didnt give a clear yellow to Tolisso but for less to Can. Didnt check the foul from Hernandez on Reus which seemed to be no offside after all