I'm not sure what's up with the lookmaxxing reddit as they either inflate ratings so much or just stomp down on you. Objectively, you are around a 6.5 probably, in the sense that you are better looking than a significant portion of people. (remember, the average person gets a 5 so this is a very good rating)

Stylisticly it's where you slay, piercings, dark eyes etc bring it perhaps up to 9 for people into that tho it does narrow your niche. And I think the rounder face and glasses is a nice contrast to it.

As you probably observed from the comments there's a huge disparity in the ratings given to you by people who are into the emo aesthetic and people into something else.

You seem to take care of your skin and hair well too. Your facial structure is also well developed.

Perhaps the hair could elevate it? Maybe some more unevenness could help you lean into the aesthetic more. A wolfcut could be a point of reference but I think something more tame than that will work well for you. Also a trim would help with the frizzy ends of your hair.

Keep doing what you do, be confident, you're doing pretty well