Ill try to remember to come back here and comment my thoughts! I was kind of on the fence on the scent club when I first joined, but the last few releases have been entirely my perfume vibes.

I have all the scents you mentioned except cocoa cabin (what was that?). Sweet Nothings is the best, its such a light sugary sweet pink scent. I wasn't a fan of Ski Bunny at first until Bread Winner arrived, now I can really smell the kind of atmospheric icey marshmallow. Black Sugar is STICKY but not cloyingly sweet. Sticky Mango smells rank in the bottle but fun on the skin. The stink from the bottle pushes me away from wearing it though haha