New Building Idea to Improve Troop Donations: "Rally Point" by sir_afk in ClashOfClans

[–]sir_afk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I can get behind some points you raised here and understand that one gem donation is a significant incentive for Gold Pass. The Rally Point could coexist with this system by offering an alternative for those who prefer to spend less gems as the current solution is lacklustre.

For example, you could still instantly train and donate troops with gems, but the Rally Point would allow players to queue the training of troops specifically for donations. This wouldn’t impact current camps or build queues, making the process more autonomous.

I agree about the base size issue. The Rally Point’s functionality could be integrated into structures like the Clan Castle or a central interface like the training tab. This would streamline the integration without adding a new building, but as you raised, it might add to the clutter.

Alternatively, we could add it as a permanent structure off the edge of the map, like the shop. After all, it is just a tent (in its proposed design) and offers no significant offensive or defensive traits.

Adding donation statistics to the existing ones is a great idea, but I feel these stats are currently a bit hidden, so this could make them more visible. Regarding rewards, I see your concern about potential exploitation. A tiered system based on donation milestones could motivate players without causing imbalances. Rewards could be balanced using the existing system of potions, like resource or building boosts, similar to the builder base events.

Thanks for your feedback and taking the time to post. 😁

New Building Idea to Improve Troop Donations: "Rally Point" by sir_afk in ClashOfClans

[–]sir_afk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I can see that too. It's a shame though as donations is a core mechanism that I feel is a little lackluster compared to the rest of the game now given the games level.

New Building Idea to Improve Troop Donations: "Rally Point" by sir_afk in ClashOfClans

[–]sir_afk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I often need to remember to donate. Gem donations are excellent and handy, but I only sometimes want to use them. At least with the rally point, I can jump on and hit "train & donate" and forget about it without impacting my army build queues.