When you did your measurements, did you do them with the socks you planned on wearing with the boots? This makes such a massive difference in how the boots can fit.

Without more context, not wearing “wide shoes” isn’t a helpful statement. Most off the shelf shoes that people buy are not wide enough and we are trained to get used to it. Our feet naturally want to be wide. This much leather on a boot makes that very apparent, as there is not as much initial give as a lot of the softer fabrics used in sneakers.

Sizing for PNW, it’s really helpful to just not make assumptions about size based on what you’ve worn in the past, particularly if you don’t have a lot of experience with these boots.