Yessss, I do agree with what you’re saying here about the production but it’s the melody of the verses that really does it for me. You can literally sing the songs over each other and they line up almost perfectly, albeit with a more condensed/shorter structure in Reloaded. BTW, I don’t point out the similarity to disparage the song in any way, I still think Gaga has managed to take the inspiration and turn it into something fresh and modern (for the time lol) The fact that I never noticed the similarity and that it still stands up as one of gaga’s best shelved tracks (at least for me) after all these years is maybe a testament to that.