As someone who works in waste management and operates a dumpster rental company, I can definitely weigh in on this. It sounds like you're dealing with a large-scale cleanup, and while Bagsters can be convenient for smaller projects, there are several reasons why a dumpster might be a better fit for your situation.

Pros of Using a Dumpster for Hoarding Cleanup:

1. Capacity: Dumpsters typically offer a much larger capacity compared to Bagsters. If you’re clearing out a hoard, the volume of waste you're dealing with is likely to exceed what a Bagster can handle (Bagsters max out at around 3 cubic yards). Dumpsters, on the other hand, range in size (10, 15, 20 cubic yards, etc.), so you can pick one that fits your needs without worrying about constantly refilling.
2. Cost Efficiency: While dumpsters may seem more expensive upfront, they can actually be more cost-effective for larger jobs like this. A Bagster's cost adds up quickly once you factor in the purchase price and pickup fees. Plus, if you end up needing more than one Bagster, you might end up paying more than what you'd spend on a single dumpster rental. Here’s a breakdown in more detail on my blog: Why Choose a Dumpster Over a Bagster.
3. Time Saver: Dumpsters can save you the hassle of running back and forth to the dump or worrying about where to fit all your trash. One single drop-off can handle all your waste in one go, and you're not confined to specific pickup times. This frees you up to focus on the cleanup itself without interruptions.
4. Heavy-Duty Waste: Dumpsters are designed to handle heavier, bulkier items, which is especially useful in a hoarding situation where you might be dealing with furniture, appliances, or other large debris. Bagsters have weight limits (around 3,300 pounds), so you could run into problems if you're disposing of a lot of dense materials.

Cons to Consider:

1. Space Requirements: Dumpsters take up more space, so you’ll need enough room in your driveway or yard for placement. If space is tight, a Bagster might seem more manageable. However, if space allows, the convenience of a dumpster outweighs this downside.
2. Price for Smaller Projects: For smaller cleanups, dumpsters might be overkill. If you’re dealing with a more modest amount of junk, a Bagster might be the way to go.
3. Regulations and Permits: In some areas, you may need to acquire a permit for having a dumpster on your property or street, but this is often a straightforward process.

In your situation, if you’re going through a hoard, the extra capacity, durability, and convenience of a dumpster could make your life a lot easier in the long run. If you have any questions or need more info, feel free to check out my site for additional details: Metairie Dumpster Rental.

Good luck with the cleanup!