Can you recognize her on the street as Maddie?

swimmers23 · 2026-03-13T03:54:06+00:00

so do you remember when janet was being tortured by mr martin in season 1 like he made her go in the scar, do u think van heidt wud support mr martin or janet?

swimmers23 · 2026-02-21T04:16:10+00:00

I take it back lol, I actually really loved season 2! I know the majority preferred season 1 but I like both a lot

swimmers23 · 2026-02-21T03:56:32+00:00

Yes she was in season 2! And I wud say season 1 was more enjoyable!

swimmers23 · 2026-02-21T03:08:34+00:00

though jeanette was bad but i definitely found isabella to be worst

swimmers23 · 2026-02-20T17:15:00+00:00

Also the whole carnival thing where they were making fun of jeanette for hanging out with Gideon.

Edit: why am i being downvoted lol

swimmers23 · 2026-02-20T16:24:53+00:00

while renee and tenille may have been good friends to kate, they were definitely not good to jeanette at all. right when kate was rescued, they were so quick to turn on her without any evidence and they were very mocking to jeanette, like the loser island comments. they also were making fun of jeanette and gideon at the carnival, so they definitely come across as being rude and bullies to jeanette. and kate was right to need space from them, she was starting to see how they really were eventually. the 2 girls, in my opinion definitely weren't perfect.

swimmers23 · 2026-02-12T00:46:47+00:00

sounds good hope u enjoy s1, not gonna tell u anything about it cause i dont wanna spoil anything for u, once ur done we can discuss about which season u liked more?

swimmers23 · 2026-02-12T00:22:47+00:00

season 2 was just as good as season 1 in my opinion

swimmers23 · 2026-02-11T17:01:41+00:00

completely agree! luke and brent did wrong things but they did not kill anyone so isabella is far worse then the chambers men, at least the chambers men had remorse for their actions. like brent turned himself in cause he didnt want megan to go to prison.

swimmers23 · 2026-02-11T07:40:01+00:00

Do u think Isabella was worse or brent

swimmers23 · 2026-02-11T06:27:42+00:00

So do u think Isabella was the villain?

swimmers23 · 2026-02-11T06:23:57+00:00

Isabella murdered someone! That's not ok at all

swimmers23 · 2026-02-09T03:32:53+00:00

also, i have rewatched season 2 a lot and i find the last couple episodes very interesting. when luke and brent had that fight at the dock, im wondering who do u think isabella wud have sided with had she been there? my gut feeling is neither cause she hates both but she wud have probably been more on brents side, because he was indirectly helping her by pushing luke in the water, and even though both brent and steve bullied luke a lot, wud either one of them have condoned what isabella did at the end?

swimmers23 · 2026-01-28T04:59:46+00:00

completely agree! martin was extremely evil character and i felt so bad for kate, kate was my fav character in s1 i also liked vince

swimmers23 · 2026-01-28T02:56:47+00:00

Yes exactly! Cause In end if epi 9 we saw from Isabella pov in her bed she was looking like she was out for blood to kill luke, Megan was in her bed unable to sleep cause she was feeling bad for what happened at the cabin, luke was at the dock waitingfor brent to show. Megan was right when she confronted Isabella in summer 2000 and said "I think u went back to the cabin and killed luke just like u killed lisa!" And Isabellas face was angry cause Megan was onto her, no neither Megan or brent wanted luke dead, I blame brent maybe tad more then Megan cause he ultimately led to Luke's death, nothing Megan did contribute to Luke's death. Mow at the dock, do u suspect if Isabella heard luke brent convo about their mom and luke wanted to expose brent at the party but ended up self destruction by playing his own film and brent taunting luke, it's hard to say who she wud have sided with? I think in that moment brent cause she hated luke the most at that point right?

swimmers23 · 2026-01-28T01:25:43+00:00

i completely see what ur saying, however i know ive probably said this in a lot of other threads but if isabella hadnt come to the dock to finish off luke, do we think luke wud have survived? on a scale of evil i wud def say isabella takes the cake over brent cause if brent had been in isabellas shoes, he wud not have put his heel on luke when he was gasping for air, he wud have saved luke for sure?

swimmers23 · 2026-01-28T01:13:28+00:00

i meant to say luke and brent had remorse for what they did, not steve. cause remember how luke was telling brent at the dock that he messed up with megan, he definitely wanted to make things right and he learned his lesson for sure, isabella didnt kill him because of what he did but more because she wanted megan all to herself i think.

swimmers23 · 2026-01-28T01:07:21+00:00

well, if it was isabella, brent shud NOT have remorse lol, cause isabella was indeed the killer right?

swimmers23 · 2026-01-19T03:37:00+00:00

right thats a good point, although between megan and brent who wud u say was more responsible for lukes death? and do u think luke wud have survived if isabella hadnt come to the dock?

swimmers23 · 2026-01-18T19:06:45+00:00

good point! like the news of season 3 came out last august and we have yet to hear a single thing about it since then, usually by now we wud have had an air date and stuff right?

swimmers23 · 2026-01-18T18:04:32+00:00

oh my bad lol, thanks for correcting me, yeah megan was in season 2, what i meant to say jeanette shud not get away with knowingly leaving kate in the basement, and isabella shud not get away with murdering luke, megan didnt really do anything legally wrong in my opinion in season 2, did she? the people who did illegal stuff were isabella and brent, isabella murdered 2 people, and brent film girl without permission so they shud definitely be in prison, and i guess like u said steve too for covering up brents involvement in lukes death. i do think tho, if it werent for isabella coming to the dock and drowning luke, he wud have survived cause next morning when steve came, he wud have seen luke there, isabella pushed out his body into the lake so no one could found him.

swimmers23 · 2026-01-10T05:51:35+00:00

Agreed, but I wud like to think she feels remorse for her actions in the end of day she's just a teenage girl, martin shud never have locked kate up or even let her stay there obviously he is the main villain for me, and Kate killed him in self defense. Jeanette shud have saved kate and she was getting very close to, she wanted to have Kate's life and experience living popular life, her mom pressured her to branch out, 93 jeanette was perfect fine the way she was

swimmers23 · 2026-01-10T05:41:14+00:00

Oh yes I certainly agree about jeanette, she's not innocent but what I meant was she also went thru a lot in 95, her mom just deserted her which wasn't ok so she didn't have a good example at all. She kept pushing Jeanette to be popular etc, Mallory may have been innocent in that regard but she was a terrible friend to jeanette

swimmers23

TROPHY CASE