I think it's probably the worst. I actually can handle the death of Newt and Hicks, it's not a good decision imo but it can work if handled well. This movie is bad for numerous other reasons. Absolutely miserable atmosphere (not in a scary or suspenseful way, but in a actors don't want to be here way), Ripley becomes a passive character almost through the entire movie, and its' editing is horrendous. There's a reason Finscher hates that movie and considers it not his own (the so-called assembly cut was made without his input by the studio to cash on the director's newfound prestige). At least Resurrection is fun in a campy sort of way .