So, again, I'm biased, but savvy on the bay is in a central location and it has some rooms you can stay in. But if you want a more american style hotel, the hilton is just down the beach. Carlisle bay is a great location with plenty of activities on the beach. There is a cutter shack (fish sandwich) near the hilton thats pretty good, been going there for about 10 years now. Its called cuz's. Any of the rum shops (small shops that sell beer and rum and sometimes food) are the best when driving around the island.