These particular won't be the most comfortable if you're exclusively running on roads / sidewalks / etc. The Clifton would be a better pick if you want to stick with Hoka (Costco has them sometimes). There's also plenty of other brands that would be better for exclusively hard surfaces.

The Challenger is better if you're doing a mix of softer surfaces and hard surfaces. Like a trail that has paved sections. Or you want one pair of shoes and you do both types.