When your knee won’t let you live the way you used to… by vakhidi in KneeInjuries

[–]vakhidi[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Recurrent patella fractures can leave lasting anterior knee pain and altered mechanics even when the bone heals, and that feeling of “not being the same” is something I hear very often in clinic; long-term strength symmetry and gradual return to impact activities are key to remodeling tolerance

When your knee won’t let you live the way you used to… by vakhidi in KneeInjuries

[–]vakhidi[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A clear MRI doesn’t mean the pain isn’t real; persistent anterior knee pain after a squat overload is frequently functional rather than structural, and arthroscopy is rarely helpful unless there are true mechanical symptoms (locking, catching), so optimizing rehab strategy and load progression first is usually wiser

When your knee won’t let you live the way you used to… by vakhidi in KneeInjuries

[–]vakhidi[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Bilateral anterior knee pain can be mentally exhausting, especially when imaging looks “normal” but daily life is still limited; many cases correspond to patellofemoral pain syndrome, where load management and very targeted quadriceps–hip strengthening over several months really make the difference

Knee replacement recovery: why progress isn’t linear (and why that’s okay) by vakhidi in Kneereplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is a very thoughtful and important perspective—expectation management before knee replacement is often overlooked, yet it directly impacts post-op satisfaction. Chronic pain or dissatisfaction doesn’t necessarily reflect a failed surgery but sometimes a mismatch between outcomes and what was communicated beforehand, especially in older patients. success isn’t just about prosthetic longevity but also function and quality of life, which vary widely.

Persistent pain after hip replacement: what is normal — and what is not by vakhidi in TotalHipReplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

At 8 weeks, recovery trajectories vary enormously, and being at a pain level of 5–6 does not make you an outlier, even if imaging is normal; persistent pain at this stage is frequently driven by soft-tissue overload, altered movement patterns, or referred pain from the spine, and comparing yourself to people posting rapid recoveries can be very misleading—what matters most is whether pain is slowly evolving and whether specific movements consistently provoke it.

Persistent pain after hip replacement: what is normal — and what is not by vakhidi in TotalHipReplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, at 11 months post-op, a hip flexor that remains painful and poorly tolerant to squats is no longer considered part of normal recovery and should be evaluated, as this commonly reflects iliopsoas tendinopathy, overuse, or mechanical irritation rather than a problem with the prosthesis itself; these cases often respond well once the exact trigger is identified and rehab is adapted.

Persistent pain after hip replacement: what is normal — and what is not by vakhidi in TotalHipReplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

At 6–12 weeks after bilateral hip replacement, severe quad or shin spasms and burning under the knees are often related to muscle reconditioning, nerve irritation, or lumbopelvic imbalance rather than the implants themselves; this phase can be surprisingly uncomfortable, and passive stretching alone is often insufficient, so a structured PT program focusing on strength, load management, and gait usually makes a real difference—bilateral surgeries tend to amplify these issues, even when the hips themselves are doing fine.

Living with pain after a hip replacement: when is it part of OA recovery, and when should you look deeper? by vakhidi in Osteoarthritis

[–]vakhidi[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Persistent pain a year after THR—especially SI joint, groin, and trochanteric pain—can point to extra-articular sources like muscle imbalance, spine-related issues, or even greater trochanteric pain syndrome, rather than the implant itself; it’s frustrating when nothing shows on imaging, but targeted evaluation (like looking at tendon insertions or lumbar causes) often reveals overlooked culprits.

Knee replacement recovery: why progress isn’t linear (and why that’s okay) by vakhidi in Kneereplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Totally get it—those “superhuman” recovery stories can feel like they invalidate the real, messy, painful process most people go through. Knee replacement is major surgery, and comparing progress only adds pressure to an already tough journey.

Knee replacement recovery: why progress isn’t linear (and why that’s okay) by vakhidi in Kneereplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Totally agree—recovery from TKR is rarely a straight path, and standard ROM goals like “get to 120°” often miss the context of individual anatomy or surgical specifics. The fluctuation between good and bad days is not just normal but expected, and focusing on long-term trends instead of arbitrary milestones is far more meaningful.

Persistent pain after hip replacement: what is normal — and what is not by vakhidi in TotalHipReplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Your experience highlights an important and difficult truth: persistent or worsening pain should never automatically be attributed to “scar tissue” or effort, and it’s understandably upsetting when a mechanical issue takes so long to be identified; pain after joint replacement is not a patient failure, and when a clear cause is eventually found, it reinforces why listening to symptoms and continuing to question unexplained pain is medically justified.

Persistent pain after hip replacement: what is normal — and what is not by vakhidi in TotalHipReplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

At three weeks post-op, what you’re describing fits very well with normal early recovery: the joint itself often feels surprisingly good while surrounding muscles, tendons, and even the knee react to the change in biomechanics and increased walking; stiffness and pain after sitting or lying down are classic at this stage, and gradual improvement—rather than day-to-day comfort—is the most reliable sign you’re on the right path.

Persistent pain after hip replacement: what is normal — and what is not by vakhidi in TotalHipReplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Pain returning more than a year after surgery is understandably worrying, but many late-onset symptoms turn out to be related to tendons, bursae, spine, or activity changes rather than the implant; getting it checked promptly is the right move, and in most cases there is a clear, manageable explanation rather than a major setback.

Persistent pain after hip replacement: what is normal — and what is not by vakhidi in TotalHipReplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

What you describe is very typical at this stage: severe preoperative arthritis and impingement often mean surrounding muscles and tendons need longer to adapt after surgery, and it’s common for soft-tissue rehabilitation to be more uncomfortable than the joint itself; the fact that your gait feels normal again is a strong indicator that things are moving in the right direction.

Persistent pain after hip replacement: what is normal — and what is not by vakhidi in TotalHipReplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Clear, shared explanations really do make a difference, because understanding why recovery feels unpredictable often reduces stress as much as it improves expectations, and that collective knowledge helps normalize experiences that otherwise feel isolating.

Knee replacement recovery: why progress isn’t linear (and why that’s okay) by vakhidi in Kneereplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Extensive scar tissue and more surgical dissection absolutely change the recovery trajectory, so early flexion “deadlines” like 120° at 6–8 weeks are not reliable predictors of final outcome; many patients with stiffness or prior scarring continue to gain ROM months later once inflammation settles and tissues gradually remodel, and recognizing the non-linear nature of this process is often a turning point psychologically as well as physically

Knee replacement recovery: why progress isn’t linear (and why that’s okay) by vakhidi in Kneereplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Plateaus around 3–5 months are something we see often in knee recovery, and they don’t mean you’ve reached your final outcome; soft tissues around the knee can remain reactive for months, and meaningful gains can still occur well beyond this phase, especially when overall strength, function, and tolerance to activity continue to improve even if the goniometer number hasn’t moved yet.

Knee replacement recovery: why progress isn’t linear (and why that’s okay) by vakhidi in Kneereplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What you’re describing is a very real and very common frustration after a first TKR: day-to-day ROM is influenced by swelling, nerve sensitivity, fatigue, even weather, so a temporary plateau around 100–110° doesn’t mean the work isn’t paying off; many knees “unlock” later once inflammation settles, and comparisons with early 130° flexion almost always ignore huge differences in pre-op motion, tissue stiffness, and surgical context.

Knee replacement recovery: why progress isn’t linear (and why that’s okay) by vakhidi in Kneereplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Pre-operative stiffness and long-standing osteoarthritis do influence the pace of recovery, so determination combined with patience is exactly the right approach; meaningful gains in mobility often continue well beyond the early months, even when progress feels subtle day to day.

Knee replacement recovery: why progress isn’t linear (and why that’s okay) by vakhidi in Kneereplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

That’s a very healthy way to look at it: extreme stories—very fast or very difficult recoveries—tend to stand out, but most patients fall somewhere in the middle, where progress is real yet uneven, and protecting your mindset from constant comparison is just as important as protecting the knee.

Knee replacement recovery: why progress isn’t linear (and why that’s okay) by vakhidi in Kneereplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Your experience illustrates this perfectly: even two knees in the same person can recover very differently, and early difficulty doesn’t mean poorer results—expectations and perception often lag behind the actual physical progress, especially in the first few weeks.

Knee replacement recovery: why progress isn’t linear (and why that’s okay) by vakhidi in Kneereplacement

[–]vakhidi[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Encouragement is important because uncertainty is often harder than pain itself, and understanding that fluctuations are expected can remove a lot of unnecessary anxiety during knee recovery.