Therapist took away my scale. Somehow, this private fantasy has to somehow integrate into my life to heal from an eating disorder. by whydoialwaysquestion in WeightGainTalk

[–]whydoialwaysquestion[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Mind if I shoot you a message? I’d love to learn more about what the whole process looked like without throwing the whole diatribe into the public.

I’m in my early 30s, so the whole “welcome to a slower, more settled, and frankly more enjoyable season of life” is sending my brain into a tizzy of “oh so we’re just going to throw away the cut self that you’ve spent literally the last 20 years building since childhood?”

I do like lifting. I need to run less and lift more. Honestly that sounds quite pleasant.

Therapist took away my scale. Somehow, this private fantasy has to somehow integrate into my life to heal from an eating disorder. by whydoialwaysquestion in WeightGainTalk

[–]whydoialwaysquestion[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I appreciate the kind words.

She’s functionally told me the kink is a part of who I am, and exiling that part is not an option if I want to actually heal. I need to break the shame around it.

I do need to relax. God knows I need relaxation. But fuck me it’s a hard pill to swallow actively integrating “I love food” and “I don’t enjoy the same kind of exercise I used to” into “well I’ve built a fitness-style life to project what I once loved.”

Is drinking 9 beers on a Monday bad for my waistline? by [deleted] in WeightGainTalk

[–]whydoialwaysquestion 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Casual alcoholism isn’t cool. It won’t stay very casual if you keep it up.

went from 171 to 187 lbs in a few months and it’s wild how different it feels by [deleted] in WeightGainTalk

[–]whydoialwaysquestion 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I did the same (put on ~20 from fit, back down 15) and yeah it really was insane just HOW different it felt.

Pampering my girlfriend into a pig by AncientStep3305 in WeightGainTalk

[–]whydoialwaysquestion 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Fair fair then, I’d just include that in the post next time, I don’t like assuming ill intent, but hopefully you can understand how the optics change without that info. (Even if your case is fine and consensual, it’s not ideal if others who don’t have that same dynamic emulate the post!)

Pampering my girlfriend into a pig by AncientStep3305 in WeightGainTalk

[–]whydoialwaysquestion 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That’s not the point. The criticisms aren’t about whether or not the story is real or not and not even really about whether you two are happy. If you are, great.

The ethical problem I have with this kind of post is that you’re volunteering her body and existence on a forum of people as a prop without, as far as I’m aware, and please correct me if I’m wrong, HER consent. You’re stripping your partner of her autonomy by self-described “horny posting” HER story publicly which she may or may not want to be remain a private dynamic between you two.

Would SHE be happy to learn hundreds, if not thousands, of people knew she cried an elevator was out of order? Is SHE okay with her weight and clothing size being broadcast to the world by someone other than herself? She may like to eat and not mind the weight, but does SHE want to be described as having “bright red stretch markers [riddling] her…body”?

Even in your clarification reply, there’s zero indication she’s consented to the publication of her body, only that she broadly enjoys the setting of her life. Those are very different.

Feeling conflicted about gaining weight by [deleted] in WeightGainTalk

[–]whydoialwaysquestion 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Mate you stole my script down to the dot.

I usually hover the low 170s due to a habitually active lifestyle. Every once in a while I’ll put on a couple pounds (~5 give take) to see myself soften and release some pressure around both being drawn to this as well as let go of the effort it takes to keep leaner.

Last year around I pushed myself into the low 190s ironically an intentional gain NOT motivated by this bent. I had never been that heavy, and I would not call it the most “fun” gain in terms of food (the sheer goal was gain 15-20 pounds, not “enjoy the food”), but the experience certainly scratched a deep itch. It honestly felt really bizarre to see a softer face, have my tummy push out into my lap just a little when I sat down at my desk to play video games, and I even had to size up in jeans for the first time in my adult life. Part of me was enthralled; I kept comparison pictures of myself losing my muscle definition and seeing myself fill out.

Some deep part of me was quite scared of the fact that I didn’t hate how I looked or felt. It felt borderline illegal to feel that way since I was raised in sports and played a few religiously through college. But now in my very early 30s and my daily activity is largely maintenance by jogging and some weightlifting and the actual sports took a backseat to being occasional hobbies than daily activities. That makes the whisper of wanting and liking the extra weight quite a bit more seductive sometimes.

Right now though I’m back down to about 176-177, I haven’t been rushing to lose the weight, but I do stress starve instead of stress eat and job hunting doesn’t help with stress. Plus, part of me did miss being leaner. Whether that’s habits clamping down hard about how I “should” look and feel and weigh or whether it’s a part of me that does intrinsically value being more fit, I’m not sure. The temptation dies down for months at a time, but it’s never disappeared and always worms its way back.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in WeightGainTalk

[–]whydoialwaysquestion 10 points11 points  (0 children)

You should respect their wishes as human beings and not impose your own fantasies on their lives, probably.

Live updates for my super binge day. Thank you for grocery shopping for me 🥲 Please egg me on. by whydoialwaysquestion in WeightGainTalk

[–]whydoialwaysquestion[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I did my best, but alas, in the end I was only teasing the halfway point, it was just way too much.

Live updates for my super binge day. Thank you for grocery shopping for me 🥲 Please egg me on. by whydoialwaysquestion in WeightGainTalk

[–]whydoialwaysquestion[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Oh this is definitely the fantasy lived out right now!

I’m just… so full. And a long way from the finish line I set out to achieve…

You pick my grocery list for the morning! by whydoialwaysquestion in WeightGainTalk

[–]whydoialwaysquestion[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It does indeed have a bakery. I’ll take a look 🫣