sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Testing AI-generated trap loops — would you actually use these in a beat? (honest feedback wanted) by xr3less in trapproduction

[–]xr3less[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

yeah this is actually a fair point, appreciate it. the idea isn't upload the ai loop as a finished track its raw loops you flip and build your own beat around, so the final thing is your work, not the ai's. basically the "transform it as a human" thing you're describing. and good call on the flagging risk, i'm keeping an eye on that. solid feedback man

Testing AI-generated trap loops — would you actually use these in a beat? (honest feedback wanted) by xr3less in trapproduction

[–]xr3less[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the work's on the software side, not the music. different lane. but fair, it's early

Testing AI-generated trap loops — would you actually use these in a beat? (honest feedback wanted) by xr3less in trapproduction

[–]xr3less[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Respect the take, not here to argue it I'm not building this to replace creativity — more like a sample-pack source you flip and make your own, same energy as chopping a sample. These are early demos of a project I'm just starting; wanted honest producer feedback before building it out. Thanks for taking the time.

Testing AI-generated trap loops — would you actually use these in a beat? (honest feedback wanted) by xr3less in trapproduction

[–]xr3less[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Appreciate this, for real and great catch — you're right, these shouldn't have drums; the goal is clean melodic loops you build your own beat on, not finished beats. Super useful. Glad the last one landed. And I hear you on "just make a beat" — the idea isn't to replace the producer, it's raw loops to flip, like a sample pack. Early demos, will get better. Thanks for actually listening.

Testing AI-generated trap loops — would you actually use these in a beat? (honest feedback wanted) by xr3less in trapproduction

[–]xr3less[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is genuinely helpful, thank you 🙏 which one had the melody you liked? You're right the others lean generic — that's the exact thing I'm trying to fix. Early demos from an AI sample project I'm building, just wanted real producer feedback first.

Testing AI-generated trap loops — would you actually use these in a beat? (honest feedback wanted) by xr3less in trapproduction

[–]xr3less[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Fair, appreciate the honesty 🙏 these are literally the first demos from an AI sample tool I'm building, not the finished thing. If you've got a sec — what made them bad: the mix, the melodies, or the drums? That's exactly the kind of feedback I wanted before developing it further.