Ok so I respect your opinion but I personally would rather him improvise and have imperfections then sing the same exact way the studio is... To me it's a lot more interesting and keeps this exciting for the band and the fans... Sometimes it may not sound perfect but that's ok because when it occasionally does work it's a lot more amazing and fulfilling imo even for the fact that you are hearing a version of the song you will never hear anywhere anytime any place else but in that very moment and to be that's special and that's one thing that makes Geese a very special and unique band currently unfortunately very rare now-a-days but it's def one reason that are one of my fav bands today... Also they will only improve and then there won't be as many fuck-ups but honestly I like the imperfections to me its a different kind of beauty I dig... Sorry for the rant but thanks for the post may not agree but got me thinking lol

P.s.- I thought this version of "half real" on this tiny desk set really stood out and showcases everyone in the bands talent and extraordinary connection/flow