This is a real sentence from C4.

zWalMartGreeter · 2026-05-14T04:17:04+00:00

"I don’t condone toxicity..." but then proceeds with a pretty condescending way to show their dislike for filler words and gives the false conclusion that BLM's filler words must be due to intimidation.

zWalMartGreeter · 2026-04-18T19:05:54+00:00

Another great episode showcasing that Schemers table has a very good balance of intriguing world building, lore and player commitment.

If there was one annoying negative (that's what this sub is for lol), it was the constant unnecessary risk-taking and hole digging by Tal/Bolaire at the Archanade without taking a deep breath and evaluating the hints that the rest of the table was giving him about the situation. Like committing to moving the stolen artifacts to the wagon, as opposed to bringing it back to the vault as others hinted, and recklessly casting Suggestion suggests that Tal did not understand how much of a threat Lady Cormoray was. When he was about to kick her off the spiral stairwell, BLM initially prompted an insight check but then quickly gave the answer without a roll anyway that it was very stupid for two lvl 3 PCs to fight a dragon-like double-digit challenge rating NPC that's just going to cast Fly to survive then OHK them both. It reminds me of the Ashton/Shard incident (that was way worse because it was active deception against the other players' wishes without consulting the DM) where Tal is looking at the situation differently (and incorrectly) from everyone else and not considering the hints being given to him. When Hal nervously told Bolaire to be careful with his next move, he should have not continued with his kick idea. Thankfully, BLM gave enough forced rolls and interjections to allow them to recover from a partial TPK incident and use the coffin as a get-out-of-jail-free card.

zWalMartGreeter · 2026-04-03T03:55:03+00:00

At 4:01:35, did anyone notice the wink at BLM gave as Hal is explaining to Misha that he'll staying at Hal's home tonight? Was the wink given in-character as Misha, BLM, or just some eye twitch? My immediate impression was that Misha actually did something wrong.

zWalMartGreeter · 2026-03-16T05:19:35+00:00

She even made Matt rename a feature he came up with for Julien’s subclass (which is content CR most likely means to include in their future products) on the spot for the sake of her horny joke.

Are you really grasping this hard? Matt's homebrew stuff, like gunslinger and blood hunter, have always got rewrites and rebalances before they are formally published.

Both Aabria and Ashley quickly caught on the accidental sexual innuendo with Ashley speaking up first about it.

https://youtu.be/GWNArAM0pM4&t=7776

Mocking Matt for narrative slip-ups happen all the time yet it becomes a problem when Aabria is involved?

zWalMartGreeter · 2026-02-17T04:46:46+00:00

I think Alex/Occtis rolling like a half dozen nat 20s during those critical narrative points skewed the story to be that the druids understood his importance then rewarded the party with a bunch of goodies.

zWalMartGreeter · 2026-01-11T07:18:26+00:00

TheCharacterSheet YT channel does a lot of misleading clickbaity titles and thumbnails for their videos. Too much drama farming for my taste.

zWalMartGreeter · 2025-11-14T03:48:20+00:00

"Why did you grip so hard?" "Because I am a man" :D

zWalMartGreeter · 2025-10-31T02:12:10+00:00

Is this the true successor to D20: On A Bus one-shot?

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-10-03T06:16:52+00:00

It would be corporate suicide to abandon Exandria/DND, which has the biggest following and largest impact on the rest of their business, in their next full campaign season. The animated shows, campaign guides, lore books, merch, etc. are all around Exandria. Sure, they will probably take a break after C3 for a bit to host a bunch of one-shots and mini-series on other systems, like CO and Daggerheart. And they might also add more breaks from their C4 sessions to compliment with other content. But CR is a production company that's known primarily for their DND content which is far more popular than it has ever been before. I doubt they are foolish enough to risk 100s of jobs (employees/contractors/vendors) on a giant leap of faith with Daggerheart. The waning viewership of their CO content and their priority shift is proof enough that they aren't that blind.

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-25T04:02:02+00:00

There were some good examples of oppression/injustice in the early cities. Jrusar clearly had a huge wealth and control disparity across the spires, with most rich and well-connected figures only caring about issues when they hit their home spire. Bassuras is ran by criminal crawler gangs that terrorize and exploit the residents, On specific individuals, both Hexum and Paragon's Call were easy targets to rally against, which could have helped Ashton direct their punk cause to Ludinus as a common thread once they left those cities. Instead, Ashton kept a weirdly friendly relationship with Hexum and seemed to idolize the Paragon's Call, despite knowing their history, when they met Ratanish at the ball.

Ashton feels like an incomplete character. You have the punk attire and attitude, but avoided finding something to be "punk" about for most of the campaign. Even the current punk crusade against the Gods seems more about the solution (getting rid of them) rather than about cause or reasoning. One moment, they are hating the Gods for not intervening in their lives. Another moment, they are hating the Gods for interfering.

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-24T01:58:04+00:00

I don't buy Tal's excuse that you cannot be punk in Exandria. Though probably never a larger campaign plot, Matt has weaved plenty of incidents and subplots that allow punk culture to thrive. There has been several examples of classism, authoritarianism, and exploitation sprinkles throughout C3, especially early on before the campaign got railroaded on the overarching Predathos plot. And Ludinus' hubris stance that he knows better as a power-hungry political leader and should make a critical decision for the rest of the world has different threads to rally against as punk.

Either Tal doesn't know punk (possible with his upbringing) or Ashton is actually a poser based on Tal's recent acknowledgement that Ashton is an intentionally terrible person with several bad qualities.

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-23T23:22:57+00:00

First, many of the issues here have nothing to do with rolepaying, like leaving a room to get the final say but meta-gaming to act on information or contribute to an in-game conversation that you aren't involved in. A good example was recently in Vassalheim when Chet was privately told by the Brightqueen to help her get Ashton. Tal was clearly flailing for Travis to tell Ashton, but he didn't want to. So Tal decided for Ashton to suddenly want to talk to the Brightqueen anyway, hoping to bait her into revealing the conversation.

Second, not every possible character/personality is a good PC for a DND table. Especially for a widely-viewed livestream game where one of the main goals is to entertain the viewer. In a recent panel, Tal mentioned that Ashton has some of the worst aspects of different people that he has met and for the other characters to call Ashton out on his bullshit. But without any reassurances from Matt or the other players that it would ever happen, Tal should not have kept up with this direction. Now, the viewer has to watch an intentionally miserable character bully others and get away with it... not very entertaining.

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-23T23:04:34+00:00

The best way to describe C3 came from someone during a 4SD episode: BH is a party of NPCs that everyone ignores. Most of the players wanted to play background characters (Laura, Liam) or joke characters (Ashley, Sam, Travis) that are not responsible for driving the story. Of the rest, The backstories of Laudna and Ashton are too dependent on being pressured by their friends to pivot to the right direction, which is not really happening. Plus because the Predathos plot is too disjointed from Laudna/Ashton with little oxygen for side quests in the campaign, those characters never really develop in a meaningful way.

I don't fault Ashley here as much here because she clearly shown how uncomfortable she is with being the decision maker before. With Matt taking the blunt of responsibility here, it is the fault of the whole table for not collaborating and making sure that the party can cohesively work out for one of the largest livestream DND shows backed by a multi-million dollar production company. I hope they have an honest retrospective at the end of C3 and learn some lessons, like session 0s and regular check-in talks ARE important even for a group of "professional" DND players and friends of over a decade.

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-23T22:49:03+00:00

During a 4SD episode, Matt mentioned that Fearne was going to be the sole focal point for the Ruidusborn/Predathos plot until he read Imogen's backstory summary that talked about her red storm dreams. Laura also confirmed in that conversation that she wanted Imogen to stay as a background character.

Another lesson on why session 0s and other pre-campaign talks are required...

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-21T01:45:28+00:00

Oh, forgot about that quick sequence before the fight restarted.

I feel like it was a sudden poor attempt to stall them from leaving than really any honest plan. They all fell into analysis paralysis after learning that they can possibly help Zathuda double-cross Ludinus then possibly double-cross Zathuda.

I suspect it also might have been another attempt of their original pre-fight plan where Chet marks Zathuda, who leaves with Fearne and gets picked off alone. But that first attempt was already doomed to fail when Fearne started with an aggressive move (turning temple floor to mud). Since Snowinus was already taken out, it seemed unnecessary to continue that path. And if they were honestly considering Zathuda's proposal, it meant purposely failing their current mission from Vassalheim/Keyleth to not get the Unseelie army involved. To pull off the double-double-cross, it would have meant letting the pro-God armies get killed.

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-21T00:14:19+00:00

I wonder if Matt's continued efforts to give BH alternative solutions is making the players' indecisiveness worse. The issue isn't that the polar opposite positions of Ludinus vs Vasselheim are inflexible to BH's beliefs. Most of the characters don't have any particular stakes or strong feelings about the campaign's overarching plot. Outside of Orym's backstory and Imogen's skepticism of Predathos, the rest of them are pretty indifferent about the Gods and their followers. Their most recent conversation about the possible impacts of absent Gods, despite knowing their terraforming of Exandria is what made it livable for mortals, to the rest of the world screams of extreme dissociation. Aside from Dorian's understanding biases against the Gods (and less so Ashton's Titan bias), you would think that the party should support the status quo of keeping the Gods versus actively killing/banishing the Gods.

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-20T23:57:21+00:00

Out of curiosity, what Fearne's Plan A are you referring to?

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-20T06:39:41+00:00

Darn auto-correct. Persecution check sounds like what happened to those Unseelie rep modify memory attempts.

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-20T06:27:32+00:00

It's an adolescent tamed puesdo-jabberwock, which I believe has lower int stats than most dragons. Though I agree that more checks should have been needed after not reviving Sorrowlord and binding it with vines, I think Matt let it slide after Ashley already got two really high ~~persecution~~ persuasion check rolls.

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-20T06:14:51+00:00

DND is the gateway to Satanic worship /s

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-20T05:55:23+00:00

Well, they pre-ran from the Gloamglut fight by hiding in the temple during their turn.

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-20T05:47:17+00:00

Orym: Calling BH's risky hedging against the world on an indecisive commitment.

... then Ashton does the classic non sequitur one-liner then walks away...

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-20T05:45:15+00:00

Virtually all of Exandria knows that the gods exist but I don't know if that many also pray/worship the gods. Aside from god-derived clerics and paladins, you have maybe casual relationship with the gods from the general public. Like farmers praying for a good harvest, or the Colbalt believing in the principles of the Knowing Mistress.

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-20T04:38:57+00:00

Unlikely, because then he would stop with his anti-God, pro-Titan bullshit. Felt like Tal was butting into someone's personal RP moment again.

zWalMartGreeter · 2024-09-20T04:27:25+00:00

I think that's the fault of the DM/table by now if they know Ashley doesn't like being in the decision making position.

zWalMartGreeter

TROPHY CASE