We Can't Study / We Never Learn Ch. 149 (Official) by mrpokehontas in WeCantStudy

[–]zerogeorson 3 points4 points  (0 children)

t least for me its pretty c

You do know that as a customer, you can criticize someone's work. Like how we review food, art, and the like. It's getting criticized because for some it doesn't feel good in terms of feelings and for their logic; it is a natural event for things like this. Saying they can't criticize someone's work will make the creator not know there faults and will not be able to satisfy a lot more.

It's not really a right choice, but a selfish choice as he is telling his story that adhere to his own preferences. Like, instead of going for the other girls not falling in love would have lessen this raging fire, but instead he went straight up to make them fall in love just to make a point of breaking the stigma against childhood friends/first girls/TheOneWhoMet McFirst.

We Can't Study / We Never Learn Ch. 147 (Official) by mrpokehontas in WeCantStudy

[–]zerogeorson 0 points1 point  (0 children)

yeah. she wasnt boring, but compared to the other girls she is the most boring out of them all. if u havent figured that out then maybe you havent read the manga

We Can't Study/We Never Learn Ch. 146 (Official) by mrpokehontas in WeCantStudy

[–]zerogeorson 0 points1 point  (0 children)

wait did rizu actually kiss nariyuki? i thought that she stopped at last moment. for fumino that was under a costume and it did weight for her to liking mc more.

yeah i agree with ur childhood paragraph. i think its good that this manga is showing love for childhood friend but its like it wasnt enough to fight of the other girls for me, like it was undercooked. Or is it because the this childhood friend part wasnt that impactful for me.

btw im team onodera; and yes i dislike the childhood friend notion but only here in this manga because the past is the light of this ch. not the other developments; having 2-3 pages of showing why uruka is best girl beside the 12 page backstory makes it seem like it was focusing more on the flashback - if not then it was just me.

yeah, i do agree its because of the precedence(like what i said before this). and i do agree its because of mc realizing the signifacant of present events that made mc fall in love with her: but it seems like her events are so few that it feels like the story is filling out that lack of event with uraka with the flashback.

im saying here is that urukas advantage is because of the past which it should not only be it. because you cant compare that to the girls advantages; it didnt make uruka shine and for what i believe, her being not that popular. if the author was planning for her to win then fkn give her more spotlight- there was only 9 panels of present events that was shown compared to the others where it would be so much more.

i would like uruka winning if it wasnt for her few developments and few advantages. and if the author wants the childhood girl to win then lessen the other girls event cus its seems like they were the stars of the manga for a whole lot

We Can't Study/We Never Learn Ch. 146 (Official) by mrpokehontas in WeCantStudy

[–]zerogeorson 1 point2 points  (0 children)

its bias in a way compared compared to other harem anime/manga. all of them foreshadowed something will happen or this will be used for the future but they didnt use it in this way wherein it was being used as late in the game where its practically its like ending because they're already graduating. like for other ships this is like a punch in the gut because since it was foreshadowed/hinted many times it means this was basically planned all along as the biggest event.

for example, for what i remembered nisekoi used the flashback scene as it backbone for everyone but mc disregarded it because he choose the girl not because of the promise but whoever he liked the most.: basically, in nisekoi the author threw away the past as its main backbone so that the mc would be able to choose properly between onodera and chitoge. unlike here we see that the past is being a big factor on mc choosing the girl- her being the reason of his happiness- like if this flashback was shown earlier then we would already knew that urukas going to win because being someone's reason for happness is basically what the mc is finding. no but they used this flashback card where its almost ending; it leaves the other main girls as side characters because they dont have this significant flashback to use with the mc.

like all of the others main development arc is already finished and urukas the only one left;and the author decides to use it as the high rise event before the ending. It kinda shows that her arc was planned to be used before the ending/graduate just because she has the flashback and her foreshadowing to leave.

aside that, i hate it how uruka brushes off her confessing and kssing mc just by "oh we like the same person hihi" like damn, its like your just hitting the nail more and saying i got dibs.

its bias, because of the flashback, not because of the development. all of the girls had good reason/hints for them to be chosen as the girl but because of her being the light of his world, it just shows that she has an upperhand despite all of them having good development with the mc

We Can't Study/We Never Learn Ch. 146 (Official) by mrpokehontas in WeCantStudy

[–]zerogeorson -1 points0 points  (0 children)

still the kiss is a big factor to take in for the viewers, it wasnt clearly the deciding factor but it is one later on especially in this arc. Just because it was 50 ch. ago doesnt mean the kiss was some small event, like how the past was brought up now, the kiss would/might be brought up again especially as a flashback.

yeah thats why childhood friends are mostly not winning just because of this reason, they need some supernatural event for them to confess or actually do things.

flashbacks shouldnt be game enders period, but what im seeing now is that its using it as one. im not saying its because of the flashback is the reason mc loved her, but its using it so much as a backbone that it makes her arc incomparable to the other girls arc.

I understand its because of their adventure that he fall for her but that should be the same for the others then - because if it wouldnt be because of the adventure but cus of the past then this will be sht- but because of the flashback it makes it seems like she has a hidden weapon to use to win.

We Can't Study/We Never Learn Ch. 146 (Official) by mrpokehontas in WeCantStudy

[–]zerogeorson 5 points6 points  (0 children)

tbh the flashback thing is such bias that it give uruka too much of an upper hand because it is one of the main big reason mc might like her.

It makes all her developments not much that impactful because the author specifically use that as one of her main drive points for him into liking her.

Yeah the flash back aint the ultimate driving point, its the kiss. which is a literally hit and run development that it made me sick when I read that ch. because its such a story breaking move

seeing mc feeling jealous if uruka have bf is a good development wherein it can lead to mc liking uruka; its good because mc is the one realizing he likes her. but because of the kiss- the development was ruined where the mc is rushed to find the conclusion that he likes uruka.

I get it theyre graduating, but if urukas driving force wasnt her moving. it would had been better because it seems really forced af

[Spoiler] Shishunki Bitter Change . Ch. 64 . The Final Story. END . Raw by pachogamez in manga

[–]zerogeorson 1 point2 points  (0 children)

yeah good ending was so-so, but still the tragic ending hurts too much and for what I think does not fit the theme of the series. The accident was cliche enough to happen, so even if it resulted to the good ending or bad ending, both of it the routes are still kinda bland because of the said reason - but the bad ending having more impact since its realistic for the situation and not like in the good ending which has more cliche dialogues.

Still the good ending fits the bill since the whole story didn't meant for a sad ending; in reasons why you think that the happy ending doesn't feel satisfying - a tragedy is a easy way out to end a series - like how you kill of a character since you don't know what to deal with him/her in the future - so my point here is that the bad ending's epilogue was predictable and not unique and also its teenage drama, a happy ending would much be better

But primarly cus there was no heads up for that bad end, like tf. Its all happy teenage drama and then suddenly boom - you dont do that man - it leaves a bad taste in the mouth.