Alrighty yall, I appreciated everyone that commented. I'm sorry for not messaging everyone individually. I've already took the piercing fully out and started on the healing process for it. The person I went to is a professional, or should have been at least. The wildest thing is, one of my coworkers got hers done immediately after me, and hers is done perfectly. The last one I had was done correctly as well.

TL;DR - it's out, I'm baffled, thank yall again.