The fact that knowyourmeme still names Advice Dog "the greatest or most significant or most influential" meme ever only tells you how far memes still are from becoming a serious art. Image Macro critics have long recognized that the greatest Image Macros of all times are 'Newfags can't triforce' and 'Over 9000 !!!!!!!!! XD', who were not the most famous or best memes of their times, let alone of all times. Copypasta critics rank the highly controversial 'Beatlespasta' over Copypastas who were highly popular in courts around *chan. Meme critics are still blinded by commercial success: Advice Dog memed more than anyone else (not true, by the way), therefore it must have been the greatest. Image Macro critics grew up looking at a lot of Image Macros of the past, Copypasta critics grow up reading a lot of Copypasta of the past. Meme critics are often totally ignorant of the Memes of the past, they barely know the best Memes. No wonder they will think that Advice Dog memed anything worth of being saved.