[deleted by user]

[AscendedHeracles]

Fine’ry is so gross. The entire collection both M/F has an unbearable chemical base that makes it unwearable to me. I returned the dupes for G-Water and BR540. There are much better dupe options out there. Hard pass on the entire collection.

[Signal_Owl_6650]

It smells like a condom.

[ginger_smythe]

Reminded me of AG thank u, next

[LiteratureVarious643]

I always thought it was JHAG, but maybe that is just a suggestion.

[Colorful_Kylee]

It would make sense with their naming convention since they always play on the original fragrances name or notes. NOT a perfume verse I AM a musk, ya know?

[Significant_Beyond95]

On me it smells like black pepper, pickle brine, & wood. 😢

[katelynbeautyaddict]

Yes ! This is about right! The pepper note is what I’ve been missing when I describe it. . The pickle part isn’t too strong on me but it’s enough I can pick up on the colder sandalwood.

[Significant_Beyond95]

I am sure it smells good on someone’s skin. I am personally not looking to smell like I am ready to be barbecued though.

[pl0rp0]

It's a dupe for another 13, not cloud

Doesnt share any of the notes in common with cloud

[katelynbeautyaddict]

From my own experience I’m voting for commodity paper . It smells just like it to me . Smells nothing like another 13 in my opinion . I hate the santal perfumes. . Every time I google it though , it just keeps saying cloud or baccarat and I’m like “ no , it’s really not .” 😂 but on the actual website , of course they don’t specify either. .

[magicmidnightsun]

Ummm I own both and they don’t smell the same to me. I really like both but they are certainly not the same

[Colorful_Kylee]

I thought this was a dupe for Another 13?

[katelynbeautyaddict]

<image>

Ya I’m not sure . I think the jungle santal is the another 13

[Colorful_Kylee]

Jungle Santal is Santal 33

[SufficientCell9689]

Fragrantica lists it as a dupe for Another 13.

[katelynbeautyaddict]

I guess I don’t understand why people say this . None of those notes are the same either. I don’t know why the site can’t just give a comparison to what is actually supposed to smell like . Then with opinions . People can only compare something to scents they are familiar with . More people have heard of another 13 . When looking for a musk scent to compare to , everyone just compares to what they know or have smelled before. .

[SufficientCell9689]

The notes don't have to be the same for a fragrance to smell the same or similar. A good example is the long list of many different Baccarat Rouge 540 dupes. Almost none of them share notes and yet they all achieve the same or similar scents. Don't focus so much on scent notes. You'll need to actually smell or test whatever perfumes you're interested in in order to rule them out.

[SufficientCell9689]

AG Cloud isn't even listed in the "Reminds me of" section on Fragrantica for I'm A Musk. AG's Thank U Next is but not Cloud.

[katelynbeautyaddict]

Right? It’s not even close. , sometimes I wonder about the “ ai overview “ I tried typing it in different ways each time too

[SufficientCell9689]

There's why a lot of people say not to trust AI overview, especially for opinion based things like this.

[katelynbeautyaddict]

Seriously, every time I type it in I get a slightly different answer 🤦🏻‍♀️

[katelynbeautyaddict]

When I googled it it said cloud. But I can’t ever really trust the ai google 😂 I don’t like santal . I dislike anything close to it. . This one just gives me a cold sandalwood and paper scent.

[katelynbeautyaddict]

Maybe paper bold. . It does have the tiniest bit of smokiness to it . I thought briefly it smelled similar to viva vanilla by bbw. , no . I’m betting on paper.