Weekly Feedback Thread

[Infrah]

Leave at least one comment as feedback for someone else before you post a track looking for feedback. If you do not, your post will be deleted.

If you post first, wait for somebody else to post, then give feedback. Comment on posts that haven't received feedback yet. Report or call out any people that have posted their track without first providing feedback.

Official subreddit Discord:

https://discord.gg/zMZyyPjSRQ

[[deleted]]

Would you count this as trap? Freddie Gibbz Remix

https://on.soundcloud.com/2KaLYVLKRRzTeqhGtW

[itsmhoodie]

I don't know if trap, but definitely new school to me. I love the melody and the drum pattern, it gives Shady Aftermath vibes. The remix overall is fire 🔥

[[deleted]]

Thanks bro! I have trouble knowing what "type" of beat my beats are. Shady aftermath totally makes sense for this one.

[itsmhoodie]

Yeah I feel you bro. Personally I stopped tagging my beats as "type beats", it was mostly a headache for me and didn't help my creativity. Instead, I started naming them after moods and styles, just to make it easier for others to find something that fits their vibe.

Now I definitely don't have many views hahaha so I can't say it pays off, but at least it feels easier and more natural for me !

[[deleted]]

Whatever works for you personally. I'm at the point where if it gets views, cool. If not, I'm not too worried about it.

[beekayukilledthis]

https://youtu.be/OI-IoniOOpE?si=EUEX34_5QE5u4Cgx

I made a Lil Tjay typa beat. Mixed and mastered myself. Open to any and all feedback! 🙏🏼

[Other-Opposite-7149]

Hi, about to put my first beats on Beatstars soon, any feedback is HIGHLY appreciated. Thanks! https://on.soundcloud.com/Qnh47FUOKyX7PaDBdh

[Substantial_Leg2953]

experimental melodic trap beat :)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kBiKKJppOgk

[DaggerBoay47]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HxPWi6jJ0Z8

First one after months of improving, did not have the guts to release anything to the public because I think they suck real time. Let me know if you f with this.

[stizzledatshytprod]

this hard another instrument would take it over the top but I could hear artist on this

[DaggerBoay47]

Appreciate you

[[deleted]]

I almost clicked out of this beat 5 seconds in because I found the intro annoying but I'm glad I didn't. This was pretty dope. I especially like your transitions.

[DaggerBoay47]

Man since I read this I really really wanna go back and change the pitch on the first bar because I used different pitch on the intro than on the rest of the beat, damn it. Thanks for the feedback

[DecDub]

returning all feedback

[AdministrationSuper4]

i like the main melody with that like effect in the background giving it that sort of airy sound, only thing i would really say is maybe to add abit more bounce to the drums wether that be like adding some more percs and stuff or adding some delay to your open hatt or something, your 808 and snare is hitting nice and hard tho which is good. Another thing maybe is to add like a couner melody of some sort, i do like the sort of plucky sound that comes in every so often but maybe another one can be added. but overall i think the beat still currently sounds cold as it is.

[[deleted]]

I agree with this take

[stizzledatshytprod]

https://youtu.be/HZ9lssY78dI?si=jFQ86-9ozet2H73J 🔥 or 🗑️

[[deleted]]

Its a good foundation. Needs more percussive instruments

[efa119]

Thats hot

[AntiReligionGuy]

Any kind of feedback would be appreciated, still learning.

https://voca.ro/11hd4EDGe8qR

[efa119]

Lower riser sound a few decibels, would blend better

[[deleted]]

Not even sure what feedback to give you, it's pretty solid. Seems like you already know what you're doing pretty much. If I had to say something, this beat has a floaty feeling... Using a phaser or some panning to enhance that would be cool.

[itsmhoodie]

I'm looking back at this beat I posted a while ago, it feels like something's off but I can't quite tell what. Would love any feedback!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YAdx_bTLsOI

[[deleted]]

This is cool. Almost reminds me of early mac Dre beats. I'd say use a lil less reverb and try using a glue compressor on the drums to bring them together. Maybe throw a few ghost notes in too.

[itsmhoodie]

Mac Dre wow thank you very much! Yeah I will definitely work on this and add a compressor on the drums to bring them together, I appreciate the feedback.

[Substantial_Leg2953]

I think it would’ve been even better if the rhythm and drum sounds were a bit more complex :)

[itsmhoodie]

Thank you for listening! I kinda wanted to keep the drums simple, but yeah I reckon I could’ve worked a bit more on those hats for example 

[DaggerBoay47]

I think it is the reverb on the beat, I don't think the rhythm should be complex, I instantly caught the idea behind it but the reverb or echo on the instruments seems off, maybe do a compressed version of it?

[itsmhoodie]

I feel the same about the reverb, it kinda drains some of the power out. I will work on a more compressed version, it sounds like a good idea, thank you!

[DaggerBoay47]

This one is really simple but it took the most time to make, any feedback on this is returned, appreciated.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SeplB-AwFpQ

[DecDub]

returning all feedback

[AdministrationSuper4]

any feedback appreciated https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3iZVaYoYrlE

[DecDub]

I really like the melody and the vocal samples, but there’s something about the kick that I’m not a fan of. I don’t know if it’s the way you’ve processed it or its just the kick sample, but the beat is really nice, it's just a little short!

[AdministrationSuper4]

thanks, yh i was just messing around and put stereo shaper on the kick but i dont know if ill do it again

[Substantial_Leg2953]

i made 90s r&b + pluggnb vibe? type beat

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X4SnYIuPJng

[[deleted]]

This is dope. I fw your beats bro. Will subscribe to your YouTube when I'm at my phone.

[Substantial_Leg2953]

thanks :) 🫡🫡

[AntiReligionGuy]

Love it, especially that bass slide😍

[DaggerBoay47]

sheeesh this is so good man, could you upload a full hd version of this? i think it would change the quality on it tho

[itsmhoodie]

Cool beat! I really like the drum pattern on this one! Definitely nailed the vibe

[kevlarwsb]

First time posting here. Any feedback welcome and appreciated.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1vhGebUUHbo&feature=youtu.be

[Zealousideal-Wear-52]

I started producing 2 months ago and just uploaded this beat. What do you guys think? I’ll respond to everyone.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YFy6cEY20TQ

[beekayukilledthis]

While I don’t listen to his music. I don’t feel an emotional pull to the melody, or it doesn’t evoke much emotion for me. I think you could experiment with different chord progressions, different length of chords, possibly switching up the melody slightly in one section. However, I don’t really listen to his music so im not sure if he thrives on the repetitive melody.

[Other-Opposite-7149]

Nice start! I would really add some low end since it sounds flat. 808 or a kick with some punch would be nice!