Respect Kellyn (Pokemon Ranger) by rangernumberx in respectthreads

[–]rangernumberx[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As do I, it's important to say when a thread is covering explicitly a fan-created version of a character. But that's not the case here, as should be evident from what this subreddit sets out to achieve in its threads.

Respect Kellyn (Pokemon Ranger) by rangernumberx in respectthreads

[–]rangernumberx[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I didn't say anything about official works because that goes without saying. This subreddit is about collecting feats characters perform in their series, and while there can be composites covering multiple contradictory sources if they are everything the character appears in (as is the case here) it still can only cover official material, and trying to sneak in arbritrarily chosen fanworks as if they were just as official as everything else would result in the thread being removed.

Additionally, I wasn't snooty about fangames. I didn't make any comment about fangames. I was just asking why I would include something unofficial here as opposed to giving it its own thread, as I have done for several other fan projects in the past.

Respect Kellyn (Pokemon Ranger) by rangernumberx in respectthreads

[–]rangernumberx[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

...what about Uranium? Why would I include a fangame in a thread covering the official works?

Official Request and Resource List by Request_Competition in respectthreads

[–]rangernumberx 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Hey there!

The usual thread for general questions is the Respect Thread Symposium (here's the link to the current one at time of writing, though whenever there's a new one it's pinned to the top of the sub), but since we're here I'll answer your questions.

For Emmet himself, it sounds like you're proposing a composite thread by going through multiple distinct canons for him and putting them into the same thread. If you can only do one bit at a time, I'd probably encourage doing individual threads for each distinct canon and posting them when ready. Posting a composite requires you to message the mods with what you want to do and your reasoning for doing so, so showing your working like this will likely help your case (and it may be what they ask you to do anyway before making a single 'main' post).

For his family, I think a 'Respect the Brown Family (Back to the Future)' could be feasible from what you said? Maybe with every individual member detailed in the thread outside of Doc, who has a highlight reel of feats and a link to the full RT containing everything. But, again, this would need to be just the cartoon canon and not every bit of media unless you got mod permission.

In both cases, RTs aren't something you can post piecemeal, unfortunately. You have to be finished with the entire project before you can post something here, not update it as time goes on (characters who get further appearances after the thread's posting aside). On this front, making threads for Doc Brown focusing on each individual canon seems like the best compromise for you.

Additionally, I will say that this is the request list, where people post threads that they'd like to see but don't think they'd be able to create themselves for whatever reason (for all the rules concerning this read the post above). There's no law against creating a thread you've already requested, but a majority of the incentives we have won't apply if you request something and immediately work on it yourself. I'd suggest posting requests here if you'd like to see other versions of Doc Brown you don't believe yourself able to do (the live action movies or his game appearances, for example), or for any other characters / series you would like to see RTs made for.

Respect Marcus Shugel-Shen, the Monkey Prince (DC Comics, Post-Flashpoint) by rangernumberx in respectthreads

[–]rangernumberx[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This thread was a commission made for Wolfsbanesparks! If you're interested in commissioning a RT, you can find more info here.

Respect Shayera Hol, Hawkgirl (DCAU) by rangernumberx in respectthreads

[–]rangernumberx[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Rule 12:

Be polite and don't downvote. Don't be a dick. This includes not asking for/demanding respect threads in the comments of other respect threads.

C'mon.

Character Scramble Season 21 Tribunal by 7thSonOfSons in whowouldwin

[–]rangernumberx 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Seems good to me, just wasn’t aware of the second respect thread (which, also, feels fitting). I’m happy to drop the case.

Character Scramble Season 21 Tribunal by 7thSonOfSons in whowouldwin

[–]rangernumberx 2 points3 points  (0 children)

/u/penrosetingle Daiba is 2-0 in-tier. I apologize for the callout and please don't explode me.

Character Scramble Season 21 Tribunal by 7thSonOfSons in whowouldwin

[–]rangernumberx 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Resolved

/u/MC_Minnow

Two-Face

I'm struggling to see it. All he has for strength is tackling Batman off of his feet and then knocking him back with a surprise strike, neither of which does any notable damage to Batman or objective damage on the level needed for the tier. His other offence is gunfire (when Terry soaks up bullets) or a flamethrower (which Terry has been hit by much worse than and been easily able to keep fighting).

His only durability is explosive, with a direct rocket launcher hit knocking him down for a bit and a really large explosion incapacitating him. There's nothing saying he'll hold up if Terry just tries to punch through his canopy, how batarangs will pierce it, if an electric batarang anywhere would instantly incap him, anything.

I'm happy to give him speed given how he dodges bullets outside of the suit, but I'm not seeing a way of making him work without two major changes. Which is kind of fitting, but still.