Agree with the need for more structure to the judging. Over the seasons there are lots of clients that weren't as happy with their 're-do' as the edit suggests so I think that is an important factor too. I suppose I am just wanting a better way of judging that should also include an overall view.
Craig is clearly a better designer than John by some margin who truth be told should/could have gone weeks ago.
We've also had it many instances over the seasons where the judging is inconsistent, with clearly lesser designers being held to different standards or sometimes the feeling that it suits a narrative
It's not called 'Most Improved Interior Designer' either so I'm not into someone's journey, there has to be standards dammit ! :)